or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › HOF: What Are You Wearing Right Now - Part III
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HOF: What Are You Wearing Right Now - Part III - Page 4436  

post #66526 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by mimo View Post
 

To be fair, I was only "thumbing" for the coat.  I like AAS's provocative style, but not this particular edition that's a Black Watch past the line. :)

 

As for Mr 38: I liked your hunting jacket, didn't like your stripey shirt with it.  Would be interested to see a full-length, and some more of what you've got.

 

 

+ 1


Edited by Sprezziamo - 12/17/13 at 7:07am
post #66527 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonCologne View Post

+1

I think the shirt is out of line with the rest. An light blue (or even a white) shirt with not to much pattern and the outfit would be a real good one.

I know I still have more learning to do, but I think I've come pretty far, and early on, I really cherished the feedback that provided detail as to what went wrong. For 38R's benefit (since I'm pretty sure AAS breaks knows the rules he is breaking), I think the unifying concern here is the formality of the Keaton shirt (compounded with bold, city stripes in 38Rs case) and silk tie with the informality of the jacket and trou. Those elements are significantly discordant. For shirts, a solid broadcloth button down collar (which, again, makes sense since you wouldn't want your collar getting in the way when hunting) would be better, or, at most, a simple windowpane OCBD. As for ties, hunting jacket like 38Rs seems, to me anyway, most at home with a knit or, at most, plaid (preferably glen or field check) wool tie.

All just how I would approach it, and shared NOT to pick on anyone or deadhorse-a.gif but solely in the hopes that I can try to do for another guy just starting out what some more patient folks around here did for me when I was starting out.

Edit: Oh, yeah, AAS: That overcoat is pure awesome.
post #66528 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

AAS, generally I'm not sure about that black watch shirt, but I am certain that it's not the right call with the rest of that fit.

+1
post #66529 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by ImTheGroom View Post

logoscompanyparty2.jpg

Wife's work Christmas party, attempt #2

Smashing!
post #66530 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by size 38R View Post

What the F#@k is that, omg that is tooo funny.

- oh, grey pants. hey i'm learning. smile.gif

FWIW, you are both wearing the wrong shirt in your fits. But there are other differences that are rather important. The general impression of AAS is that he has both an understanding of fit and coherence and why he wants to break some rules. Not everyone here thinks he does so successfully by any means, and sometimes he makes outright mistakes that everyone will agree on. But he has a certain style. He's firm about that but open enough to listen and incorporate criticism without losing his style or becoming 'boring'. And he's a constructive, thoughtful, polite and valued member.

In contrast, you claim that you have style, more style than everyone else in fact. You claim you know the rules and have the clothes to carry them off, but you chose not to - because you have style. But you don't show us style. Your oufit here, like every outfit you have ever posted here that I have seen, doesn't give the impression of a 'next level', devil-may-care, rule-breaking dude, but of someone who needs to (re)learn how to dress at quite a basic level. It's not about being boring, it's not about having to wear grey trousers, it's about learning to know what looks good together (and when grey trousers might actually be the best choice not just the default option).

The first step BTW is to have the humility to recognise and admit that you really need to learn and not to disparage the possibility of learning. AAS understands this intimately and it's one reason he's both a better dresser and a better poster than you.
post #66531 of 78717
 
Originally Posted by Cleav View Post

Not sure I've seen a good pair of cords with a crease. Something akin to a crease in a pair of jeans, doesn't work for me gents.

 

All my cords have (something approximating) a crease. They don't hold it with the same intensity as, say, worsted wool trousers do but I prefer that to zero crease. Obviously, I wouldn't crease jeans, but I think cords - especially narrow wale cords - occupy enough of a middle ground to take them. Anyway, the world can judge for itself, as I'm wearing a pair of cords today.

 

Originally Posted by jasonmx3 View Post
 

Wore these at a weekend afternoon party. Would appreciate comments on the SC fit and tie/PS combos.

 

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

 

The tie & square are fairly unpleasant to look at, though I can imagine the square working fine in a different context. The tie, not so much. And regulars here know that I wear some wacky (read: SF considers them exceptionally ugly) ties, such as today's. But I draw the line at this this one.

 

More fundamentally, the tie & square are party while the rest of the outfit is very sedate, so the combination struggles to work meaningfully. I half-suspect you chose them in order to lend some festive flavour to a conservative outfit so as to make it more suitable for the afternoon party you mentioned. That never really works.

 

Originally Posted by Pingson View Post

Thanks of all the thumbs from yesterday! Really counting the days to the holiday break, I seriously need a few days off....

Another consistently good outfit, Pingson. I get like you close to a holiday. I actually enjoy what I do a lot, but as soon as I get near a long break, suddenly I start to feel tired and can't wait for a few days off!

 

 

 

Getting in the festive spirit...

 

jwyhZtx.jpg

post #66532 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pingson View Post

Thanks of all the thumbs from yesterday! Really counting the days to the holiday break, I seriously need a few days off....



Details etc (Click to show)


Nice Pingson. You're done grading, and I'm still grading. How narrow are your ties? Is that one 8cm?

post #66533 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

RD10, I much prefer the slippers with the awesome tartan DJ. With different shoes, I'd really like the day look, too. So I'll just pretend you wore other shoes. smile.gif

 

I would expect nothing less from you, SB.  :)

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cleav View Post

Like that day jacket RD10, all good from knees up

 

Thanks, Cleav.

post #66534 of 78717
AAS and Tira are excellent examples of successfully executing the approach 38R espouses. And that they are both respected members is proof that there is plenty of room for that type of approach to be accepted.

It is infinitely harder and riskier than what I do, so like the outfits or not, I have immense respect for the sartorial whimsies of both posters. Labelking as well, though he was well before my time.

ETB, I may ask for royalties for that last pose.

Jason, I really liked the look on the left from afar, but the sheen of the tie and the fold of the PS don't work for me. I think TV folds are best reserved for white linen, and barring that, at least solid squares. A TV fold can't really show enough pattern to have any real effect, so ultimately it feels incomplete.
post #66535 of 78717

Kind of awkward pose

 

 

post #66536 of 78717

^ killer socks and shoes!

post #66537 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by Claghorn View Post

AAS and Tira are excellent examples of successfully executing the approach 38R espouses. And that they are both respected members is proof that there is plenty of room for that type of approach to be accepted.

It is infinitely harder and riskier than what I do, so like the outfits or not, I have immense respect for the sartorial whimsies of both posters. Labelking as well, though he was well before my time.

 

Honestly, this is what I'm interested in as well. I can throw on a suit in the rare occasions that I have to wear one, but for the day to day this kind of dress doesn't let me show my personality.


AAS' and Tira's approach is just way more in sync with what I want out of a dress wardrobe. Polished yet playful.


I love the more trad/business look that many of you gents have. It's awesome. You guys look friggin' great!

 

It's a helluva learning curve though!

post #66538 of 78717
pingson, great.

crusty, looking like a godfather.

mimo, nice top block, but tie knot needs help.

cleav, nice color, but i wonder if that is too large a PoW for a tie. ymmv

thanks for all the likes yesterday, gents.
post #66539 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by size 38R View Post


while you raised some standard points.  the fit was put together for a reason. as you know by now, i can dress "approved" if i want to- my wardrobe is worthy.smile.gif
(but i simply find the concept of "approved" to be distasteful and against this forum's original intentions, which is to celebrate style, not bland. )

i am a business man in a semi-Rural area. and my style reflects my personality and occupation.

post #66540 of 78717
Quote:
Originally Posted by Holdfast View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pingson View Post

Thanks of all the thumbs from yesterday! Really counting the days to the holiday break, I seriously need a few days off....
Another consistently good outfit, Pingson. I get like you close to a holiday. I actually enjoy what I do a lot, but as soon as I get near a long break, suddenly I start to feel tired and can't wait for a few days off!


Getting in the festive spirit...
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
jwyhZtx.jpg

Thanks HF!

I really like the green SC with the red/burgundy(?) trousers. I would just prefer another tie (although I get what you are after) - a solid or regimental striped wool or cashmere tie would look smashing with that outfit.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TweedyProf View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pingson View Post

Thanks of all the thumbs from yesterday! Really counting the days to the holiday break, I seriously need a few days off....
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

Nice Pingson. You're done grading, and I'm still grading. How narrow are your ties? Is that one 8cm?

I usually go for 9cm ties, but that one is indeed 8cm. Berg & Berg (where the tie comes from) unfortunately only make their ties in 8cm width. This one looked so nice that I bought it anyway, but I always feel a little sting of sadness that it isn't wider whenever I wear it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by in stitches View Post

pingson, great.

fistbump.gif
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
This thread is locked  
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › HOF: What Are You Wearing Right Now - Part III