I'm beginning to think you like blackwatch, AAS.
Really like the jacket in the first pic, but I feel like the SC is out of place. Yes, I am a grey POW jacket-wearing hypocrite. Not sure what would be a good replacement though. Navy is probably too dark with the vest. Maybe some sort of tweed or a big, bold windowpane? If you lost the vest, I think the SC works better, as would navy. Just my opinion.
Like the shoes too.
Very nice SC, but it seems like the tie and square sort of come out of left field. Perhaps it's the combo of the two?