One will still look good in ten years. One will be comedy. Spot the difference.
Tie green is a little bright and I think there's a bit too much tartan overall in the fit. I can see what you're going for though.
I like that tie. Just ugly enough to be the kind of thing I dig.
Glad it's Friday; it's been far too busy a week...
PS. inlandisland - to answer your query, the critters on yesterday's tie were flying ducks. :)