Originally Posted by bringusingoodale
^some would say that is too tight. But if you are as slim as the OP, a shirt that fits like that wouldn't raise any concerns.
That's my point. He's fit, why hide it?
Originally Posted by rioni
^^ that shirt is way too tight
I respectfully disagree. It may be too tight for your tastes, but it's not objectively too tight. It's not pulling anywhere, it's unbelievably comfortable and at the same time conforms to the aesthetics of my style.
Originally Posted by TheWraith
A lot of bad responses in this thread, IMO. The sizing is only slightly off, not as bad as some people here claim. One of the reasons why you really shouldn't ask for size opinions on this, or any other forum, really. You get some really bad responses from people who (for the most part) are confusing opinion with fact, and don't really have the knowledge (barring the odd exception) to be making a proper, informed opinion anyway.
I think most people were identifying some or most problems correctly. I'm sorry, but in picture #4 it looks like the OP has some kind of misshaped, deformed chest. In others, there's pulling and bunching of fabric. It's far from an ideal fit. However, I mostly agree. Most of us here have no experience cutting and making shirts ourselves. But it doesn't mean we can't identify some of the problems. And anyway, after giving my opinion I posted a picture of what I think is a good fit (on me). If he likes it, he can follow my advice. If not, he can ignore it. His choice.