or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › CBD WAYWRN: An Experiment
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

CBD WAYWRN: An Experiment - Page 14

post #196 of 7027
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton View Post
I don't want this thread to become a discussion of "Is X CBD or not?" I think that would get dull. And, it misses the point.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eustace Tilley View Post
...'in my neck of the woods this is/isn't CBD."... I don't think that was Manton's intention with the '7 continents' remark.

I just think of it as "how to dress soberly but still stylishly".

Regardless of local professional customs, I think the principles of CBD as defined here can help in dressing better at all levels of formality and location.

Thanks for starting this one Manton. Even though the original CBD threads were jokes (and funny ones at that), the underlying discussions were really valuable.
post #197 of 7027
Quote:
Originally Posted by Parker View Post
I just think of it as "how to dress soberly but still stylishly".

+1 - well put

Quote:
Originally Posted by Threadbearer View Post
That's a BB tie? Looks too lux and textural for the Brethren. Do they still sell that one, or is it Old School?

Looks like one - stripes are from R-to-L, unlike British repps.
post #198 of 7027
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MBreinin View Post
(simply because I would not want to be that "bow tie guy")

This is as good a test as any. If wearing a bow tie makes you known as "that bow tie guy," don't do it. If it's, "Oh, that's Brenin, he's a lawyer. Yeah, he likes bow ties." That's OK.
post #199 of 7027
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eustace Tilley View Post
^ This thread will only get more and more interesting as everyone chirps in with a 'in my neck of the woods this is/isn't CBD."
I think a little of this is useful. It's interesting to learn what flies and what does not in various regions and industries (and combinations thereof.

What I hope this does not become is purely a thread about dress codes. It should rather be a thread about dressing well. Ascending from the dress code.
post #200 of 7027
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eustace Tilley View Post
I don't think that was Manton's intention with the '7 continents' remark.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Parker View Post
Regardless of local professional customs, I think the principles of CBD as defined here can help in dressing better at all levels of formality and location.

Fair enough. This discussion is certainly more interesting and useful to me than most of what I've read on the forum lately.
post #201 of 7027
Thread Starter 
Call this "Conservative Church Dress" (CCD):







Brown shetland herringbone jacket, blue OCBD, navy knit tie, maroon ground paisley square, light gray flannel pants, blue & gray wool socks, unlined #8 shell loafers.
post #202 of 7027
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton View Post
Call this "Conservative Church Dress" (CCD):

Brown shetland herringbone jacket, blue OCBD, navy knit tie, maroon ground paisley square, light gray flannel pants, blue & gray wool socks, unlined #8 shell loafers.

I may be mistaken but I thought you had elsewhere mentioned you hate wearing buttondown collars with suits.
post #203 of 7027
Looks good, but I feel that the parts are a bit disparate with this one - almost as if the coat and PS belong to one family, while the ocbd and knit tie were borrowed from another look.

I personally would have been tempted to pair the herringbone coat with a checked shirt (BD or moderate spread) sans tie.

Is that ocbd from one of the SG fabrics?
post #204 of 7027
Finally MC has a true analogue to the SW&D waywt thread.

In the SW&D one, people post outfits that they wear when hanging out casually. In this thread, people post outfits that they wear to work. In both threads, people are posting stuff that they wear in real life, and the outfits are judged by real life standards.

The main MC "waywt" has no such real life connection. It's become mostly a bunch of guys peacocking for their friends on the internet, trying to win friday costume theme challenges etc.

The stuff posted in this thread is very good. I will only note that in every business environment I've ever been a part of, the standard attire is a worsted wool suit and silk tie and dark brown or black oxfords, no pocket square. Not saying that there's anything wrong with wearing wool ties, knit ties, pocket squares, bluchers, suede shoes, etc., but I wouldn't call them "CBD" because they are, like it or not, a fashion statement. I would wear that stuff only on days when I don't face clients.
post #205 of 7027
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by deadly7 View Post
I may be mistaken but I thought you had elsewhere mentioned you hate wearing buttondown collars with suits.

1) You are mistaken.

2) That's not a suit.
post #206 of 7027
I love everything about that, Manton ^.
post #207 of 7027
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eustace Tilley View Post
Looks good, but I feel that the parts are a bit disparate with this one - almost as if the coat and PS belong to one family, while the ocbd and knit tie were borrowed from another look.

I personally would have been tempted to pair the herringbone coat with a checked shirt (BD or moderate spread) sans tie.

Is that ocbd from one of the SG fabrics?

The cloth is whatever CEGO sells, I think Carl said it is Japanese.

Checked shirt would, IMO, be too busy, though I do wear OCBD candy stripes with it. I really don't like spread collars with tweed, except for tatersalls in brushed cotton. Don't have any of those any more. Used to. Not sure if I would wear one now in any case. Very "English" in a way that would make me feel dress-uppy. I like the American-ness of the OCBD.
post #208 of 7027
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton View Post
The cloth is whatever CEGO sells, I think Carl said it is Japanese.

Checked shirt would, IMO, be too busy, though I do wear OCBD candy stripes with it. I really don't like spread collars with tweed, except for tatersalls in brushed cotton. Don't have any of those any more. Used to. Not sure if I would wear one now in any case. Very "English" in a way that would make me feel dress-uppy. I like the American-ness of the OCBD.

Maybe its just my budget monitor, but isn't that a solid brown coat (albeit with a h-bone pattern)? If so, why would a checked shirt be 'busy'?

I'm loving my OCBD's as well, and can't believe I didn't buy any earlier. I think my inner-snob always equated them with a RTW, middle-America, look. I always wear mine w/o a tie though.
post #209 of 7027
I have never encountered a business environment where pocket squares were not appropriate. In France, nop one would even notice a square unless it's particularly flashy. In London, I saw many people without squares but also many with - I don't think anyone really cares. In NYC, squares seem to be somewhat frequent in financial and legal circles although they're clearly not prevalent, and tend to be worn by more senior people - which may create a little bit of an awkward feeling for younger workers. That said, no one ever made a comment to me (in an ultra CBD environment) about wearing a fairly sober square, even when I was quite junior. Brown shoes on the other hand attracted a lot of comments - and even an express prohibition to wear brown shoes to client meetings with one specific senior guy.
post #210 of 7027
I'm not sure how I feel about knit ties in regards to CBD. Whenever I've worn one, I've found it draws comments. I think I'll like this thread, I usually dress far more conservatively than WAYWN, I don't realy like drawing attention to myself with my clothes.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › CBD WAYWRN: An Experiment