or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › CBD WAYWRN: An Experiment
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

CBD WAYWRN: An Experiment - Page 8

post #106 of 7015
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton View Post
Sigh.

I hate to explain jokes but ... the original CBD threads were ... jokes! Everyone has forgottent the troll Kasper/Joseph K. Bank. But he was prolific at the time and the threads were inspired by his schtick.

This thread is not a joke, or at least not intented to be. I really did wear this to work. I work in a conservative place. Suit & tie every day. No casual Friday. My boss even wears his jacket in the office. I never see odd jackets on people on my floor. (People visiting are another story.)

So, yes, this about "CBD" but it's also about what you can do to CBD without straying from the straight and narrow.

Or, at least, it's about what I do.

Interesting thread - I like the concept, and a challenging first post. I confess I would never have considered brown pebble-grain with an office suit, only with a country suit. Brown oxfords, or black derbies I would have considered fair moves from the past conventions, but these surprised me.


Quote:
Originally Posted by onix View Post
I really want to hear what Manton has to say about the current submissions. I still only half understand his concept and perspective on CBD.

+1

Checked suits, brown suits? I'm interested in where this thread goes.
post #107 of 7015
I can't be bothered taking a new photo yet, so here is an old photo once posted here. perhaps some old timers will recognize.



LP wool/linen
Bespoke shirt
Forgotten brand tie

the non-CBD element is a pair of shell loafers worn without socks.
post #108 of 7015
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton View Post
Shoes & socks:


oops, i don't remember that i sent you a pair of shoes...
post #109 of 7015
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slewfoot View Post
I'll play...something I wore recently...the marks on the mirror are from that distressed "bistro style" type glass...critique away...already know Foo's feelings on the white linen square. :^)

This is very good.

I have gotten DB shy lately. The two that I will wear are a gray flannel in about that shade and a navy. I actually have two of the latter, in different shades. I am the only person I have yet seen in my my entire office ever to wear DB. Yet I feel that those two are subdued enough that it's OK.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mafoofan View Post
Too many solids.
No, it looks good. Three solids is an enduring classic that is never wrong.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mafoofan View Post
Silk is rebellious? I almost exclusively wear silk squares.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eustace Tilley View Post
You've probably discussed this elsewhere, but why no linen? I probably wear linen squares 8 out of 10 days.
I wear silk with a woolen tie always, and in fall winter, most of the time. Linen is more for spring summer for me. Foo's dislike of white linent makes no sense to me.

It looks like Slew tried to fold his in a puff, which I would not recommend.
post #110 of 7015
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by MBreinin View Post
This is the fit I caught flack for in terms of the cashmere tie not being CBD.



That's a great tie. Fit of the coat looks a bit off.

I think the narrow guage of the stripes on the shirt and suit are too close. If you are going to shoot for three patterns, either one has to be almost imperceptible or else the scale of the two should be radically different.

For me, a two stripe ensemble almost demands a solid tie. This comes off as too many lines. When mixing three patterns, I would make the tie a dot or a neat of some kind.

Finally, if you are going to go more or less monochromatic with the main elements (nothing wrong with that), it's best to throw some color into the sqaure. Also, always silk with a woolen tie.
post #111 of 7015
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by gdl203 View Post
CBD when it got really




Please do notice how the tie's background picks up the the color of the


I have a vest a lot like that. I have not worn it to the office in a long time. Not sure why. I used to. Maybe it's because this year I got a heavy OC and that took care of the cold.

We'll see if I crack that out next year. For weekends with an odd jacket, a sweater vest in winter is something I wear a lot.
post #112 of 7015
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Moo View Post
What does the thread think?


Surprisingly good. I would fold the square to show more brown and less white, and also cram it down a bit more.
post #113 of 7015
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by maomao1980 View Post
I can't be bothered taking a new photo yet, so here is an old photo once posted here. perhaps some old timers will recognize.



LP wool/linen
Bespoke shirt
Forgotten brand tie

the non-CBD element is a pair of shell loafers worn without socks.

This is great, but socks are required. Also, I have never gotten over, and probably never will, my phobia of loafers with suits.
post #114 of 7015
...per maomao1980's pic for example, and replacing the shirt with something like this http://www.brooksbrothers.com/IWCatP...=&sectionsize=
or should I stay with solid? Thanks..
post #115 of 7015
Quote:
Originally Posted by maomao1980 View Post
I can't be bothered taking a new photo yet, so here is an old photo once posted here. perhaps some old timers will recognize.

I think I remember this - did one of the accompanying shots feature a glass of champagne?

It looks good. I like the blue on blue on blue.
post #116 of 7015
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton View Post
No, it looks good. Three solids is an enduring classic that is never wrong.
"Never" is a strong word. Even if it's possible for an all-solid outfit to look good, you still have to carefully coordinate the pieces so that they form a cohesive aesthetic whole. The particular outfit in question does not achieve that. Each solid is completely unrelated to the others.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton
Foo's dislike of white linent makes no sense to me.
I'm next level. Actually, it's not white linen I dislike. I dislike non-white linen. I just think white linen is far less optimal than commonly accepted.
post #117 of 7015
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mafoofan View Post
"Never" is a strong word. Even if is possible for an all-solid outfit to look good, you still have to carefully coordinate the pieces so that they form a cohesive aesthetic whole. The particular outfit in question does not achieve that. Each solid is completely unrelated to the others.
?

Gray suit + blue shirt is "unrelated" yet nice. Similarly, a maroon tie goes with both. I don't think that's really disputable.
post #118 of 7015
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thanks SF (a new me) View Post
...per maomao1980's pic for example, and replacing the shirt with something like this http://www.brooksbrothers.com/IWCatP...=&sectionsize=
or should I stay with solid? Thanks..

for CBD, the suit has enough surface interest (wool/linen blend, faint herringbone), a solid shirt would be more ideal.
post #119 of 7015
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manton
The idea is to show what CBD is, how it can be bent, and -- crucially -- what the old-timers, or at least me, mean by "classic style."

Quote:
Originally Posted by gdl203 View Post
II thought the point of the thread was to show CBD and ways one can deviate from the C part to a certain extent. I mean, the OP is quite indicative of this idea. Cashmere tie, pebblegrain bluchers.

I hope people remember this. I'm interested in what the long-termers gut feelings tell them they can and can't get away with. That has got to take a lot of repetitions, so I hope this thread has legs.

My favorite (besides MaoMao's, but that is almost cheating) is Slewfoot's, just because it seems so soporific but it is double breasted. Manton's reaction is great: "db-shy lately", which I read as: good but right at one edge.
post #120 of 7015
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › CBD WAYWRN: An Experiment