So I've shot a variety of borrowed or rented shotguns over the past 5 years at the range (going 4-6x a year, so not really often). What I know is:
1. I don't want a pump. I can give up all hope of a second shot with a pump
2. I've done better at all 3 games with o/u than anything else
3. I like the simplicity (from a maintenance perspective) and aesthetics of an o/u, but that's not a major concern
4. I want versatility
Having read this thread and spoken with a variety of salesmen, I think the right option is a semi. I got shown a beretta 3901 that seemed pretty good and was under my budget, a used super black eagle, a 391 urika, and a used citori.
Can anyone comment on the 3901? I'm leaning that way (it seems to be the most rational option) but I still kind of want the used citori.