or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › **The Official Shoe Care Thread: Tutorials, Photos, etc.**
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

**The Official Shoe Care Thread: Tutorials, Photos, etc.** - Page 769

post #11521 of 19048
Don't need replacing. This is normal.
post #11522 of 19048
Quote:
Originally Posted by lexxdeleon View Post

Do I need to get the heels of my trickers replaced already?

The "toplift" definitely needs replacing toot sweet. If you wear them much more you'll wear through the rubber and into the leather of the heel block. Not good.
post #11523 of 19048

So who is 'right' on the issue of these heels? DWF, you write of the danger of wearing down the heel sack. If shoes are resoled and heeled, isn't the stack removed with the sole?

 

It strikes me that, with a lot of shoes, the toplift is very thin and might well wear down very quickly. Those who walk a lot, every day (as does Patrick), must wear down toplifts like it's going out of style. 

post #11524 of 19048
Munky,

What you're seeing in the photos is a toplift. If it is worn much more it will start wearing away the leather lifts in the stack. To repair a stack that has been worn into the damaged leather, lifts must be replaced or "patched." Usually with a "skiver."

In either case, it costs more money--time & materials-- unless the cost of making such repairs is built into the price of a toplift replacement. And in the case of the "patch," it's never going to have the integrity of the original undamaged leather lift. Or the same colour...which with very light coloured heels blocks could be a factor.

If the shoe is resoled with a half sole, the stack need not be touched except to clean old cement off of it. And, in some ways that's almost the ideal solution, esp. on RTW, as it avoids disturbing the heelseat which is often nailed and clinched.

If a fullsole is done, yes, the stack will be removed and remounted but not necessarily replaced...but the damage to the stack will still need to be dealt with.

PS (and on edit)...as near as humanly possible, heels should be kept "square" whether they be whole rubber heels or just toplifts. Too much wear on the heel (usually outside corner) will throw the gait off and make the shoe run over to the lateral side (induced supination) and cause excessive and accelerated wear of the outsole.
post #11525 of 19048


PS (and on edit)...as near as humanly possible, heels should be kept "square" whether they be whole rubber heels or just toplifts. Too much wear on the heel (usually outside corner) will throw the gait off and make the shoe run over to the lateral side (induced supination) and cause excessive and accelerated wear of the outsole.

THAT's why I'm always blowing through my outsole. I walk like a duck and always wear out the center of the outsole, after I've worn down the outside edge of the heel. So you're saying if I have that black rubber replaced more frequently, I will have to replace the outsole less frequently?

post #11526 of 19048
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScuffedBluchers View Post

THAT's why I'm always blowing through my outsole. I walk like a duck and always wear out the center of the outsole, after I've worn down the outside edge of the heel. So you're saying if I have that black rubber replaced more frequently, I will have to replace the outsole less frequently?

No, if you're wearing the outsoles out in the center, you're fine--that's where a healthy foot in a balanced shoe will wear out.

I'm saying that if the heel gets worn down too much, esp. on the outside corner (which is where most people of European decent tend to strike), the foot will tend to walk-over the welts on the outside edge of the outsole. And there will be greater wear along that outside edge of the outsole, as well. Additionally, once the shoe is walked-over, it will tend to walk over. And it will tend to always have that distorted look.

I don't suppose that most people who care about their shoes will wear the heel to that point, but I've seen stranger things and it tends to be self-reinforcing--you got away with wearing it a little too long last time, surely it won't hurt to wear it down just a little bit further this time.
post #11527 of 19048

If I've got this right, then DW, a new rubber piece on top of the heel needs replacing just before the wear is into the rest of the stack. If this is the case, it seems to be that a high degree of obsolescence is built into a pair of shoes. I don't walk  long distances and I wear my shoes in rotation. A pair of brogues that is around a year old are beginning to wear at the heel. Can I look forward to repairing heels at the rate of a pair a year, even with relatively light wearing?

post #11528 of 19048
Quote:
Originally Posted by Munky View Post

If I've got this right, then DW, a new rubber piece on top of the heel needs replacing just before the wear is into the rest of the stack. If this is the case, it seems to be that a high degree of obsolescence is built into a pair of shoes. I don't walk  long distances and I wear my shoes in rotation. A pair of brogues that is around a year old are beginning to wear at the heel. Can I look forward to repairing heels at the rate of a pair a year, even with relatively light wearing?

Munky,

Why would you expect it to be any other way? Shoes are our interface with a fairly hostile micro-environment. Any other way of thinking about it is, IMO, wishful thinking.

Yes, heels ought to be replaced on a regular basis. If you want the skill and the feel and the look of a stacked leather heel, you have two choices--a relatively thin toplift (or a partial) that needs to be replaced to prevent damage to that stacked heel; or a leather toplift that will almost certainly, wear down faster than rubber. And yes, you can use heel plates and closely spaced iron nails, etc.. to prevent the toplift from wearing out so fast. Many old gunboats have heels made exactly that way.

But then we're back to the same old arguments about Topy or rubber outsoles. If shoes are nothing more than utilitarian, then Crocs or clogs or wooden shoes ought to suffice. Or, for real durability and "What, me worry?" maybe something like this:



and "shoe porn," is a malaprop and an exercise in futility and self-delusion.

If you're not interested in the delights of a stacked leather heel, then up to one inch heels ( and sometimes more) can be replaced with a "whole heel"--one inch of rubber. Which may last about the same length of time as the thin toplift before they start throwing the shoe...and the foot ...off balance. Maybe even the body itself--I notice that my spine tends to go out of whack more readily when my heels are run down.

When I think about shoes I marvel how...over the course of their history...so many techniques, so much of the overarching philosophy of western shoemaking evolved to actually be replaceable. That good shoes can be repaired...without much difficulty or skill, if it comes to that.

But like anything that has an intrinsic value beyond the utilitarian, it requires some attention and maintenance and certainly something more than cavalier indifference.

Just riffing...nothing personal...

--
Edited by DWFII - 11/13/14 at 4:42pm
post #11529 of 19048

DWF, Sometimes you make me smile!  I am not at all sure that I was exhibiting  'cavalier indifference', just keenness to learn something about heel stacks!  Yours, as ever, Munky. 

post #11530 of 19048

basic question. when shining shoes, do you avoid putting shoe polish, conditioner, etc. on the shoe stitching? how are the stitchings cleaned?

post #11531 of 19048
Quote:
Originally Posted by Munky View Post

DWF, Sometimes you make me smile! I am not at all sure that I was exhibiting 'cavalier indifference', just keenness to learn something about heel stacks! Yours, as ever, Munky.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DWFII View Post

Munky,

Just riffing...nothing personal...



I don't think so either...but anyone who has ever done repair will tell you that it's not all that uncommon...even among affluent "gentlemen." Maybe moreso.

Only "sometimes?"

--
Edited by DWFII - 11/13/14 at 4:40pm
post #11532 of 19048
Quote:
Originally Posted by DWFII View Post



I don't think so either...but anyone who has ever done repair will tell you that it's not all that uncommon...even among affluent "gentlemen." Maybe moreso.

Only "sometimes?"

--

 

Thanks for chiming in with that great info, I'll have to get the lifts replaced asap and keep an eye out on my other shoes as well. Now to find a competent cobbler in Orange County.

post #11533 of 19048
I normally suggest that when the worn area of the heel gets down to about the thickness of a dime it's time to replace. This way the customer gets the most use out of a pair of heels without damaging the base.
post #11534 of 19048
Quote:
Originally Posted by lexxdeleon View Post
 

Do I need to get the heels of my trickers replaced already?

 

I've probably only worn them around 45 times now and it's a little disappointing if that's the case, but the rest of the boots are in really great shape.

 

 

 

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by DWFII View Post


The "toplift" definitely needs replacing toot sweet. If you wear them much more you'll wear through the rubber and into the leather of the heel block. Not good.

as DWFII mentioned the "toplift"  (didnt know it called this way, i always called rubber guard hahaha) needs replacing as soon as possible (no more specification needed as  DWFii provided everything )!!

 

the thing i want to point out more is that 45 times and that result its quit too fast for what i know!! maybe the rubber was too soft for the tureen you were walking on!! i have used the half rubber/half leather  toplifts from vibram(among other brands also) and these are far more durable than any other!!!

 

ps. happy to see you all back here after my absence!! (had a surgery )

post #11535 of 19048

Welcome back, Benhour! I hope that everything went well and that you are recovering well. Very best wishes, Munky.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › **The Official Shoe Care Thread: Tutorials, Photos, etc.**