So yesterday I polished up my shoe to a pretty shine and left it to dry over night to finish my shine today and I got to work. But when I did, the shine from the previous day was getting messed up and got more matte instead of becoming more shiny. Does anyone know what I'm doing wrong? Do I just need to apply more layers? I'm following J. Fitzpatrick's method of mirror shining at the moment.
too much polish, esp if a soft cloth leaves a trail when you rub