or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Shell cordovan - elaborate joke or conspiracy?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Shell cordovan - elaborate joke or conspiracy?

post #1 of 18
Thread Starter 
I wore my C&J/Polo cordovan ankle-jodhpurs today. Got a tiny sprinkle on them from the door to the car, the car to the office door, etc. Looked down at them on errands on my way home and they had nasty looking little spots all over them! I've heard of this but I hadn't seen it to this extent. After getting home I polished the bejesus out of them. But who knows if it will help - after all, I did polish them when I first got them. I just sprayed some water on one as an experiment, so we'll see what happens.

Anyway what are your experiences with cordovan in rain? I've noticed that some cordovan seems to refuse polish - it just smears around forever and never sinks in the way it does on leather. And can you get a real shine out of it like you can get a mirror finish on leather? It always seems to end up a bit waxy and/or rough to me. I like the look of it, but I wonder if it's possible to get it really shiny.

Side note - never break in wholecut shoes that don't fit snugly. If you get a pair that you insist on keeping but they aren't snug to begin with, put in insoles or whatever until they are snug before allowing them to break in creases in the leather. I thought these were pretty snug but in hindsight I should have put in thicker insoles (I don't think a 1/2 size down would have fit) before wearing them, because now they have a lot of creases on the uppers. I don't think it will look bad after they are broken in a bit more, but if I had it to do over again, I wouldn't wear them without having them snug in the first place.
post #2 of 18
Cordovan, in my experience, get's little raised "dots" in the rain that disappear when it dries.

I almost never polished my cordovans: usually just a good brushing. The very very few times I polished themwas with a tiny amount of polish, and I think it was a special type as it was marked specially for cordovan. (Allen Edmonds has polish that's marked for cordovan, whether or or not it's any different I don't know.
post #3 of 18
No, I've worn shell cordovan in the rain and have found that they polish up nicely afterwards once tried. Hope it all works out for you.
post #4 of 18
Being that Cordovan comes from a Horse's Ass it just might be an elaborate joke


P.S.: If those C & J's are a size 11D, I'll help you stop being the Butt of a joke
post #5 of 18
My polo cordovans and BB Aldens regularly get pretty wet, but thankfully never get bumps.

The Aldens positively gleam after a brushing. The Polos I can't seem to shine much at all, except for the very toe tip.
post #6 of 18
FWIW, the AE store folks recommended their Cordovan cream for the Leeds I purchased and said not to use a wax as it would build up. So far I have followed their advice and have been pleased.

Perry
post #7 of 18
I've never had any trouble with cordovan in rain--in fact, I probably wear cordovan shoes in the rain more than any others, mostly because they tend to have rather stout soles. But then, of course, my cordovans have usually had years to find themselves and get comfortable in their skins before they become acquainted with my feet. For all I know, new cordovan may be a bit different. Just keep in mind what you already know: cordovan is tough and will only get better.
post #8 of 18
sorry J, no problem in the rain. I did have trouble, in the begining, getting them to shine, due to putting too much wax on. by using a piece of wet nylon stocking and rubbing hard, I got a great mirror shine.
post #9 of 18
I've gotten those little spots you describe on my cordovan shoes, from rain. A tiny bit of wax polish takes care of it for me.
post #10 of 18
Thread Starter 
Hmm, yeah they look fine now. I'll see how they do in the next rain. I wonder why the surface of these and some other cordovan shoes I've seen is so rough in parts, though. Is that normal for a 'good' shoe? Shouldn't they try to put the smoothest parts on the toe and counters?
post #11 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by j
I wore my C&J/Polo cordovan ankle-jodhpurs today. Got a tiny sprinkle on them from the door to the car, the car to the office door, etc. Looked down at them on errands on my way home and they had nasty looking little spots all over them! I've heard of this but I hadn't seen it to this extent. After getting home I polished the bejesus out of them. But who knows if it will help - after all, I did polish them when I first got them. I just sprayed some water on one as an experiment, so we'll see what happens.

Anyway what are your experiences with cordovan in rain? I've noticed that some cordovan seems to refuse polish - it just smears around forever and never sinks in the way it does on leather. And can you get a real shine out of it like you can get a mirror finish on leather? It always seems to end up a bit waxy and/or rough to me. I like the look of it, but I wonder if it's possible to get it really shiny.


I tend to wear my cordovan shoes on rainy days, J. The old "is cordovan warmer than calf" debate not withstanding, I tend to think that my toes are toastier in thicker soled Alden cordovans.

I have seen bumps develop in the rain, too. For what it is worth, Alden says that you should never try to polish your cordovan shoes when wet. I thought the fear might be that you could take up one of the bumps, (Pull the scab off of the wound?) but that is pure speculation on my part.

I hear people talking about polishing their cordovan shoes to a mirror finish, and am green with envy. I can do that regularly with calf, but have never been able to do it with cordovan. I also have wondered about the unevenness (the roughness) on some of the Alden cordovan shoes that I have. Regardless of where the bumps come from, could this be a case of "natural state of the raw material adds character" ?

Bic
post #12 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by j
Hmm, yeah they look fine now. I'll see how they do in the next rain. I wonder why the surface of these and some other cordovan shoes I've seen is so rough in parts, though. Is that normal for a 'good' shoe? Shouldn't they try to put the smoothest parts on the toe and counters?

This is certainly not too uncommon for shell. Mine haven't done that, but it happens. As you've noted, it goes away, and there is no permanent damage. Remember that shell cordovan is basically a handmade product with much variation. In other words, don't worry...be happy.
post #13 of 18
So once it rains, how do I dry the shoes off?
post #14 of 18
a t-shirt will do it.
post #15 of 18
J, very strange. I go out of the way to wear cordovan in the rain, and buy cordovan boots for just this purpose. It is denser than calf and something in the membrane (whatever gives it that "waxy" appearance) keeps out the rain. The shoes never soak through, or even come close. Can't say that about calf. I have never had a spotting problem, either. I have cordo from Brooks (Alden), Vass, and Carmina.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Shell cordovan - elaborate joke or conspiracy?