or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › what do you think of these shoes?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

what do you think of these shoes?

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
http://www.newandlingwood.com/product.php?id=133

I can't stop drooling . . .
post #2 of 10
It's a nice double-monkstrap.
post #3 of 10
I like them
post #4 of 10
A really expensive reincarnation of a Grenson Masterpiece. Paul Stuart had a similar model about two or three years ago, also in the fall season. This particular version is a bit more chestnut/red than the version offered by PS. It was a nice shoe--a lighter version of the John Lobb Derwent IMO.
post #5 of 10
They caught my eye way back. But with shipping you're looking @ nearly $800.
post #6 of 10
I hate to be the naysayer, but these shoes don't really work for me. A shoe with a strap is essentially dynamic; it must (at the very least!) appear to be functional. A well-designed monk will show tension at the buckles. This is the basic drama of the monk. A double monk is a bit trickier, but potentially even more pleasing and beautiful--at its best the double monk will show the straps being pulled in slightly opposing directions as the shoe is fastened. As in this Koji Suzuki shoe:
http://www.oshitate.com/products/oth...1/client51.htm
Notice how those straps work and how the buckles seem precisely balanced to close the shoe just so. The N&L shoe is, by contrast, fairly moribund and monolithic. The straps do nothing and may as well be false (like the magnetic closures on womens handbags). There's certainly no need for two of them in this design, so it carries the extra burden of appearing gimicky. I'd save my money for one of the new JL monks (Vale or Chapel) or else I'd look around for a nice EG Westminster.
Just my two cents.
post #7 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by pejsek
I hate to be the naysayer, but these shoes don't really work for me. A shoe with a strap is essentially dynamic; it must (at the very least!) appear to be functional. A well-designed monk will show tension at the buckles. This is the basic drama of the monk. A double monk is a bit trickier, but potentially even more pleasing and beautiful--at its best the double monk will show the straps being pulled in slightly opposing directions as the shoe is fastened. As in this Koji Suzuki shoe:
http://www.oshitate.com/products/oth...1/client51.htm
Notice how those straps work and how the buckles seem precisely balanced to close the shoe just so. The N&L shoe is, by contrast, fairly moribund and monolithic. The straps do nothing and may as well be false (like the magnetic closures on womens handbags). There's certainly no need for two of them in this design, so it carries the extra burden of appearing gimicky. I'd save my money for one of the new JL monks (Vale or Chapel) or else I'd look around for a nice EG Westminster.
Just my two cents.

Pejsek, All of this is well and good, and I certainly agree with you.

But given your track record, why not wait till you see a superb pair of double monks( JL, Cleverly, etc.) in a Thrift for $5.00 or less!
post #8 of 10
Well, yes, rnoldh. You're certainly right. That's exactly what I would do. I was simply trying to give some reasonably sensible advice to those not so fortunately situated! I don't think most here would take me seriously if I suggested they save their $800 and buy a lifetime's worth of shoes at the thrift store.
Actually, if you look at my post from a little while back showing a couple of my EG shoes you will find a nice example of the double monk--the reworking of the Westminster for Paul Stuart (rescued, of course, from a thrift).
post #9 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by pejsek
Well, yes, rnoldh. You're certainly right. That's exactly what I would do. I was simply trying to give some reasonably sensible advice to those not so fortunately situated! I don't think most here would take me seriously if I suggested they save their $800 and buy a lifetime's worth of shoes at the thrift store.
Actually, if you look at my post from a little while back showing a couple of my EG shoes you will find a nice example of the double monk--the reworking of the Westminster for Paul Stuart (rescued, of course, from a thrift).

Pejsek, I apologize if I seemed to be critical. I think it's wonderful that you find these amazing treasures in the Thrifts. Alas, I've never had that kind of luck in the Houston area. I guess that the Bay Area is Thrift Store Heaven! Remember, when you first described some of your finds, I thought you were in Fantasyland. I'm glad you now have a camera, and post pictures of some of your finds.

I must admit that I get a kick out of your finds of EG's and JL's for $5 or whatever. A lot more excitement and fun than buying them retail somewhere.

I'm sure that you've noticed, as I have, that there are many SF members as well as AAAC'ers that can afford retail for their EG's and Jl's, but still try a Thrift now and then for fun. Part of the reason I'm sure is the idea that they might be able to duplicate some of your finds. That's the fun part of it.

Regards,
rnoldh
post #10 of 10
rnoldh, I didn't think you were being critical at all. I thought, rather, you had me pegged. Almost all of my clothes are thrifted. Thrifting has it all for me. It's fun, cheap, and recycles unwanted goods. Even better, it's given me basically all the clothing I want (and then some). Plus, I have a 120 year old house that's always asking for money. Thrifting may be a little better here in SF than it is in some other places, but finds are always to be had. I'm sure Houston has lots of great stuff floating around. The one key to thrifting is to do it regularly.
Still, I can't really wholeheartedly suggest thrifting as a way for most people to build a wardrobe. It takes a good deal of time and you can't just go out looking for specific things. In a situation such as this, for example, it's extremely unlikely that you could take the afternoon off, hit a few thrifts, and come home with a great pair of double monks.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › what do you think of these shoes?