SimplyStylin
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2015
- Messages
- 312
- Reaction score
- 280
I previously posted in this thread photos of my Hardings, whose soles had completely cracked. Subsequent to posting in this forum, I contacted Johnston & Murphy, who asked me to mail them back to them for inspection. I did, and they replaced both pairs. But, a year later, they're cracking again. The cracks haven't gone all of the way through, so I can still wear them as "beater" shoes, but its certainly not worth resoling them, putting new heels on them, etc.
Do you think that Johnston & Murphy would replace them again? On the one hand, at the price I paid for them, I wasn't expecting the highest quality in the world, but their sole has cracked completely through twice in three years.
3 years total use for a pair of shoes at the price is great IMO, even if it took a warranty repair to get there. I probably would expect a year to a year and a half of real wear out of a pair of sub $150 shoes (depending on how much you wear them of course), so I'd personally move on once they fall apart much more.
Last edited: