Rothman apparently was a discounter of some sort, so this may have been a house brand.
It looks very similar to the vintage coat that kitonbrioni has posted pics of (the one on the far right, sorry for stealing your pic kb):
The Eldridge I have is quarter lined as well, the pockets are very similar as are the turned back sleeve cuffs.
There's only one button hole on the lapel on my Eldridge, but it actually is functional as there's a button high on the right side that it can be attached to. It also has a lapel buttonhole flower catch on the underside of the lapel beneath the buttonhole, a feature I've only seen elsewhere on Oxxford.
Originally Posted by pejsek
Hmm, is that a theological dictionary I spy peeking out from behind the right (!) shoulder?
It's actually a book on Soviet Photography, but I put a different cover on it to throw people off...