Just received my chestnut yearling Comfort Craftsmans from bootsonline.com and I am very impressed! I ended up going with size 10.5 G and the fit is perfect for me. I typically wear 10.5 in Alden and 11 in AE. I am really surprised how comfortable they are right out of the box, i will definitely be getting another pair in the future.
Barry from bootsonline.com is terrific. I ordered two pair of yearling craftsmen about 4 yrs ago (black & chestnut) and both are still wearing well, look like new and one of the most comfortable boots/shoes I own.