Recent Images In This Thread
Related Forum Threads
- ISAIA NAPOLI - SUPER HUGE MEGATHREAD - Suits, Sport Coats, Jackets, Pants, Ties, Hangers &... Last post on 11/13/13 at 7:07am in Classic Menswear Classifieds
- PRICE DROP! BNWT -Zegna - Navy Blue. Fully Canvassed. 40R suit - !PRICE DROP! Last post on 10/19/12 at 8:02am in Classic Menswear Classifieds
- Taking in the Sides of a Suit Jacket Last post on 8/28/10 at 3:55pm in Classic Menswear
- BELVEST Super 150s Navy Blue Solid DB Suit - 52 IT ~40/42 Last post on 12/2/13 at 2:36pm in Classic Menswear Classifieds
- Phineas Cole Suit - Blue Pinstripe 38 / 32 Last post on 6/4/13 at 10:02pm in Classic Menswear Classifieds
How Should I Start My Business Wardrobe?
Last edited: 5/16/13
- What Should I Wear To A Job Interview?Last edited: 7/25/13
- Andrew Lock
- The Armoury
- Bespoke England
- Bison Made
- Blue Owl
- Carson Street Clothiers
- Conrad Wu
- Crane's Country Store
- David Reeves Bespoke
- Drinkwater's Cambridge
- Elite Suits
- Equus Leather
- Exquisite Trimmings
- A Fine Pair of Shoes
- Foster & Son
- Four Horsemen Shop
- GABE Tailored
- Gentlemen's Footwear
- Gordon Yao, Hong Kong
- The Hanger Project
- Henry Carter Neckwear
- Hiras Fashion
- Howard Yount
- Hugh & Crye
- Kent Wang
- Luxire Custom Clothing
- Malford of London
- Meermin Mallorca
- Moda Republic
- Modern Tailor
- Need Supply Co.
- Neo Nouveau
- No Man Walks Alone
- Oak Street Bootmakers
- Passaggio Cravatte
- Paul Evans
- Portland Dry Goods
- Roden Gray
- Saddleback Leather
- Self Edge
- Taylor Stitch
- Temple of jawnz
- Uncle Otis
- United Stock Dry Goods
- Vastrm Fashion
- Virtual Clotheshorse
- Wrong Weather
- Yellow Hook Necktie
- What Should I Wear To A Job Interview?
my visit to Napoli & Mina @ Napoli Su Misura - Page 229
Styleforum Top Picks
The issue is not "shoulder treatment," as you describe. There are different ways of attaching the sleeve to the body, including the "spalla camicia" or "waterfall/shirring" method you mention. But that is not what's at stake. The problem area is the line of the shoulder, between the collar and scye.
You're confusing what's at stake with what's at issue. What's at stake is almost nothing. But that's never prevented a good StyFo battle royale before.
Maybe I will. Have a few new things coming.
The only reason nothing is at stake is because Styleforum has become #menswearforum. I can't remember another member making a single sustained, meaningful critique of an "artisan's" work in at least a year. Everyone is gah-gah for everything.
Like I've said, half the art of bespoke is on the client's side. You need to learn how to work with your tailor, not simply accept everything he says and does. A healthy give-and-take is how to get the best results.
All of you discussing the shoulder treatment on NSM jackets have to keep in mind that Mina does indeed ask the customer what type of shoulder he wants. I remember she asked me if I wanted the "waterfall/shirring" on shoulders of my coats and I said yes. I don't know what other shoulder treatment she does as I did not ask but that leads me to believe that they do have different shoulders which might contribute to some of the inconsistency you are seeing on different coats.
That's a very useful information. If they ask upfront what shoulder expression treatment the customer wants, it's logical that this information is used as a basis to decide which shoulder line is more appropriated for that particular coat and customer.
In my opinion, the "natural pagoda" is a discreet way to bulk up the shoulders of the wearer. Not as imposing as the pagoda shoulder line and not as slouchy as the natural shoulder line.
Per your previous post, the "premise" of my judgment has nothing to do with NSM's intentions. The premise is that the shoulder line is bad. Whether intentional or not is secondary at best, irrelevant at worst.
It is not a pagoda shoulder. A pagoda shoulder is fully concave, from collar to shoulder point. A single curve. The NSM shoulder line is not a single, concave curve. It is convex, like a natural unpadded shoulder, up until an inch or two before the scye, at which point it swings upward into concavity. You can call it an improperly executed pagoda, or an improperly executed natural shoulder, but it is bad whatever the name.
I see, so you weren't judging whether the shoulder line was intentional or not, you're just stating that it's wrong. Fair. Honestly, I'm not versed enough to enter on this discussion, as I've no impressive historical knowledge on tailoring. So I'll not agree or disagree with you on that matter.
What I can do is to reason with what is given to me. What I call a "natural pagoda" (upturn + half of a natural line) is on some NSM garments and on garments from others artisans. You seem to not like it. However, I do appreciate this shoulder line, being a historical error or not, and, while liking it, I'm not blind to the house style characteristics that aren't to my taste.
We've many exemplars of NSM garments that present the natural pagoda, so, in my opinion, we should regard it as a house style's characteristic The use, however, is not very clear to me, yet.
Google "natural pagoda" and see if you find anything. Seriously. Doesn't exist. A pagoda, by definition, is not natural. You can't legitimate something just by giving it a name.
That's a cool information, did you solve the "problem" by adjusting the scye? It would be nice with we had photographs to compare, as without tailoring qualifications I can't quite picture it.
I'm not legitimating it, I've just said that I'm not qualified enough to discuss whether it is legit or not. Also, I'm sure that natural pagoda will not give any results on a google search, I just made that up. My goal with the name is just to have a more respectful way to speak about someone's work.
By the way, what are the key aspects of a coat's silhouette, in your opinion? Some aspects that just seems to be details to me get way more attention for others, so I'm trying to refine my definition on the key aspects of a coat's silhouette.
I never had the scye fixed because I didn't want to throw more money at the problem and just moved onto bespoke. Someone earlier in this thread thought they were being very clever by posting a seven-year-old photo of me with "natural pagoda" shoulders. They were on the MTM Oxxford jackets I went to Naples to replace with Rubinacci.
Well, I'm not very keen on discussing education values, so I'm just going to give you this reply and leave it to that. In my opinion, paying someone does not entitled me to treat his work as something purely rational, it's a human's work, especially if it an artisan's work. His work and his reputation are the key things that put food on his table so I'm going to show some respect to his work. However, this does not means that no constructive criticism is going to be given, just keep in mind that the line between constructive and offensive is very tenuous and varies between cultures.
Regarding your Oxxford jackets, I'll search for the pictures, thanks. Any clues for my question about a house style?
As for your other point: I don't think it is doing anyone any good to hold back criticism. Neither NSM, nor any other tailor, is doing anyone any favors. They take money for their work. It is not art or charity. It's clothing you worked hard to pay for. We don't hold back our critiques of restaurants, plumbers, doctors, etc. Why are tailors different? Don't fool yourself.
Those who have ordered from Anderson & Sheppard.
- my visit to Napoli & Mina @ Napoli Su Misura
- › The official thrift/discount store bragging thread 44 seconds ago
- › Official Guitar, Amp, Pedals, and Gear Thread 57 seconds ago
- › Longwing Non-Shell Recommendation Help 1 minute ago
- › The WAYWT Discussion Thread 1 minute ago
- › No Man Walks Alone - Official Affiliate Thread 1 minute ago
- › Recent purchases - Part II 2 minutes ago
- › Romantic Europe meets NYC: the ROBERT GELLER thread 2 minutes ago
- › Things that are pissing you off. 3 minutes ago
- › Technical Outerwear 4 minutes ago
- › Red Wing Boots - Your Opinion 4 minutes ago
- › Alden Ravello Shell Long Wing Blucher by ppith
- › Sterlingwear Navigator Peacoat by ppith
- › Campbell Cooper Waxed Cotton Motorcycle Jacket by njhunt
- › J. Crew Rugged Classic Boots by Red Wing by _cameosis_
- › Loake Strand by wurger
- › Adidas x The Soloist Rod Laver Vin by BenMusch
- › Loake 1880 Aldwych by wurger
- › Herschel Ravine Black/Tan FA 12 by pfmicks
- › Vans Footwear The Barbour Classic Slip On Sneaker,10.5,Green by ATLnoob
- › Berg & Berg unlined silk bow tie (SS'13) by MTB-85
- › The Tyre-Kicker's Diary: Watch Boutiques... by mimo
- › Choosing Men's Designer Suits by LA Guy
- › San Francisco Shopping Map by LA Guy
- › So you want to design your own clothes? by DaveJames
- › Styleforum Product Reviewer Questionnaire and... by alyssaw
- › Styleforum Product Reviewer Terms of... by alyssaw
- › Styleforum's Winter Getaway (Start your... by alyssaw
- › Styleforum's Winter Getaway (Extras) by alyssaw
- › Styleforum's Winter Getaway (Jeans &... by alyssaw
- › Styleforum's Winter Getaway (Cardigans) by alyssaw