Quote:
Originally Posted by
norcal_indy 
I have two pair of stows - 10.5UK and 11UK - and 11D in Alden Truebalance fits perfectly.
The 10.5UK Stow fits okay with thin/medium socks but overall is a little short. The width is definitely okay, though.
The 11UK Stow feels great with any kind of sock.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
norcal_indy 
11D US in Wolverine 1000 Miles is a perfect fit.
I would buy an 11 UK for my next pair of Stows. I currently have both 10.5 UK and 11 UK and the 10.5 is a little short.
Now that I've received my Stows, I thought I could add my sizing experience to the mix... While I have no experience with Alden's Barrie and Trubalance lasts which you guys often use as a reference point, my understanding is that those 2 lasts run .5 size large, i.e. Brannock US9D = US8.5D Barrie and Truebalance. It is also my understanding that it's suggested to size down .5 for Wolverine 1000 Miles. Given the above, I'd say my experience is similar to norcal_indy's, e.g. US Brannock size - .5 = UK Stow size. Now onto how I got to this...
Almost everyone in this thread has suggested a full size US/UK conversion for Stows, so Brannock size - 1 (or Barrie - .5). I figured I'd go with the popular choice and initially ordered/received a UK8 for my US9D feet. Right away, I realized the boots were too short, even though I was only wearing thin dress socks. Sure, I could slide my feet in, but I could also feel the end of the toebox. It's worth noting that I usually wear med weight cotton or wool socks with boots (not super burly winter weight ones though), so there was no doubt these would be trouble. And so the size 8 went back to Pediwear and I just received the UK8.5 today. As suspected, these are a bit on the roomy side, but I need that extra .5 to allow for my feet's natural rolling motion when walking.
While the 4497 last is not a perfect fit for me, I am confident UK8.5 is the right size for my feet. Ime, it's much easier to know with certainty that a shoe is too small than if it's too big. If in doubt, buy the smaller size first; your feet will tell you if you've made the right choice. Worst that can happen is you need to return/exchange. Better that than having a lingering doubt that they're too big...
Fwiw, I wear a US8.5D in RW GTs and those fit great (= .5 down from my Brannock size, for those who are still following). GS commented that the GTs are long and narrow, while the Stows are short and wide. I totally agree with his observation.
Another thing: Tricker's uses a .5 conversion US/UK as their standard, not a full size conversion. You can see this reflected in their ebay listings for shoes/boots made for the US market where they list both sizes. While I realize the 4497 is roomy with a .5 conversion, I believe it's meant to be worn that way, as are a lot of boots. Tbh, I've no idea how you guys manage to wear 1 size down from Brannock in these, even with thin socks.

In the end, I'm glad to know that if I do want a snugger fit, I can always add a Dr Scholl gel insole.
/sizing rant