or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Tyrwhitt Shoe Quality
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Tyrwhitt Shoe Quality - Page 4

post #46 of 57
Quote:
Nope, several people recommended against the black boots, including me. As an owner of both colors, I second the notion that the quality of the leather on the brown boots really is superior.
I noticed on pediwear.com and Loake's own website that the black boots come in "polished leather" (I assume that means corrected grain) whereas the browns ones are available in the same leather type as well as "waxy leather."

I believe CT carries the black ones in corrected grain and the brown ones in waxy leather. Perhaps that explains the difference.
post #47 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmInAm
Someone posted a link not too long ago to a place in Australia that ships RM Williams around the world at below (Australian) retail. I don't remember the URL, though; you'd have to dig through the archives to find it.


The RM Williams source is bootsonline.com.au. I haven't used them. RMW also has a store in NYC.
post #48 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by dusty
It's ridiculous to lambast CT for not having the same quality as a shoe that costs over twice as much (assuming the eternal CT codes of course). And for the record I'm very happy with my CT chukkas.
If you buy from this website you can get a pair of yearling leather Craftsman for LESS than the price the Charles Tyrwhitt are charging currently. http://www.nungar.com.au Even if CT were offering their %50 off deal the price would still be highly competitive. Why pay a few bucks less when the difference is heaven and hell? I just ordered a pair of kangaroo leather Stockman jodhpur boots from this website for about $250 USD (including GST - or VAT as it is called in the UK). http://www.nungar.com.au/shop/descri...03.166.249.136 I decided to get them after comparing this and a similar pair of jodhpur boots made by JM Weston in the flesh (about 700 Euros). The JM Weston has finer stitching, and finer leather with much more refined channel stitching, but when you try them on you notice that the RM Williams chisel toed last is much more elegant than the round nosed JM Weston last used in that model. RM Williams mostly uses yearling leather that is still very good and if you order in leathers such as kangaroo and veal calf the differences then fail to justify the ridiculous price difference. I mentioned this forum to Steve, the guy that runs the website and suggested that if he advertised here or made himself known he would sell LOTS of boots here. I also suggested a special offer for forum members but I haven't heard back. If you do buy from Steve may I suggest you all make the same suggestion - if enough people do it he may relent. BTW I am planning to write as definitive a thread on RM Williams boots as I can after much research. I hope to include stuff about the differences in the leathers they offer including special order leathers.
post #49 of 57
I have a pair of RM Williams Craftsman boots.

I rate them very highly indeed.

I ordered mine online from a company in Australia, who were very helpful, and I avoided vat etc. I think they worked out at around £125 including postage. A great deal, they are worth the £185 full price, but I like a bargain.
post #50 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sator
BTW I am planning to write as definitive a thread on RM Williams boots as I can after much research. I hope to include stuff about the differences in the leathers they offer including special order leathers.

I'm really looking forward to this, as my trigger finger is getting itchier and itchier everytime I read about the Craftsman. I'm just waiting for a broad base of input on their sizing/fit.
post #51 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by Joel_Cairo
I'm really looking forward to this, as my trigger finger is getting itchier and itchier everytime I read about the Craftsman. I'm just waiting for a broad base of input on their sizing/fit.


Me too. I like their Simpson boots and the Craftsman in kangaroo might be a nice change of pace but they only come in G fitting? Wonder how side that is.
post #52 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sator
If you buy from this website you can get a pair of yearling leather Craftsman for LESS than the price the Charles Tyrwhitt are charging currently.

http://www.nungar.com.au

Even if CT were offering their %50 off deal the price would still be highly competitive. Why pay a few bucks less when the difference is heaven and hell?

Thanks. Great pricing. The web site is a little confusing. Any idea what he means by "voucher pricing" on the Yearling Craftsmen?
post #53 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by edmorel
Me too. I like their Simpson boots and the Craftsman in kangaroo might be a nice change of pace but they only come in G fitting? Wonder how side that is.

The Craftsman is available in an H fitting. The Simpson boot is on a last called the G Joey last and is runs a half width wider anyway. I have to drop down one size for the Simpson.

I am less keen on the Simpson boot. The last is an awfully snubbed nosed rounded toe last. It is also emblazened with the RM Williams logo on the side which I think is a serious aesthetic blemish. I sent an email to RM Williams lamenting these fact. When they have such beautiful lasts such as their chisel toe last, the narrow medium toe, and the wide toe last they are shooting themselves in the foot in using the G Joey last for their Chukka boot.
post #54 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sator
The Craftsman is available in an H fitting. The Simpson boot is on a last called the G Joey last and is runs a half width wider anyway. I have to drop down one size for the Simpson.

I am less keen on the Simpson boot. The last is an awfully snubbed nosed rounded toe last. It is also emblazened with the RM Williams logo on the side which I think is a serious aesthetic blemish. I sent an email to RM Williams lamenting these fact. When they have such beautiful lasts such as their chisel toe last, the narrow medium toe, and the wide toe last they are shooting themselves in the foot in using the G Joey last for their Chukka boot.


So, what's up with the "voucher pricing" section?

And what do you think of the chestnut vs. the black? The Chestnut is so dark, it's hard for me to tell just how different from black it looks in person...
post #55 of 57
Get the chestnut.

The pics are unclear but in reality the dark tan is a mid tan and the chestnut is a dark tan.
post #56 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sator
The Craftsman is available in an H fitting. The Simpson boot is on a last called the G Joey last and is runs a half width wider anyway. I have to drop down one size for the Simpson.

I am less keen on the Simpson boot. The last is an awfully snubbed nosed rounded toe last. It is also emblazened with the RM Williams logo on the side which I think is a serious aesthetic blemish. I sent an email to RM Williams lamenting these fact. When they have such beautiful lasts such as their chisel toe last, the narrow medium toe, and the wide toe last they are shooting themselves in the foot in using the G Joey last for their Chukka boot.

Thanks, did not notice that about their Simpson boot. Would the H fitting not be wider than the G? I am looking to go narrower not wider. Do they have an F fitting?
post #57 of 57
Quote:
Originally Posted by edmorel
Thanks, did not notice that about their Simpson boot. Would the H fitting not be wider than the G? I am looking to go narrower not wider. Do they have an F fitting?

No they don't. That's why I had to drop down a size. I have posted sizing information a couple of times before. If you do a search you will find it.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Tyrwhitt Shoe Quality