Quote:
Originally Posted by
edmorel 
Didn't I answer this already

Yes, you can find similar Tiffany-like items cheaper in other places. But, take the two pieces of the same exact jewelry and put it one in a Zales box and another in a Tiffany box, and I guarantee you that your girl will have a very different reaction to the item in the Tiffany box. So you figure out whether that is overpriced or not.
Aww, come on, that's not quite fair. I agree that you pay a premium for the Tiffany name, which often isn't worth it, but the workmanship is much better than the garbage at places like Zales or Kaye. Just look at the refinement of the edges and welds. Also, the design and taste level is certainly superior. Plus, as another poster pointed out, a couple hundred bucks can't buy much in the way of jewelry to begin with. Anything made with gold or gems at that price point will look terrible or be very low in quality. You might as well get something in sterling silver that is styled nicely and finished well. Tiffany offers a lot of sub-$500 jewelry that may be "over-priced" for the materials used, but their lower-end things are also much nicer in other ways than what you can get elsewhere. That said, I think places like Tiffany and Cartier make much less sense when design is less important than craftsmanship. You can get better quality work from a top-notch jeweler (who are admittedly as hard to find as a good bespoke tailor) for cheaper--but we're talking about $10,000 pieces and up, not a $200 necklace. Engagement rings are a good example. After all, Tiffany and Cartier are still mass-manufacturers. Just as with tailoring, there are limitations which stem from that.