BB MTO Shirt or Moderntailor

I'm trying to decide on whether to give the BB MTO Shirt experience a shot, or to go with my first Moderntailor shirt.

Here's my situation: I need a couple staple shirts in solid blue, white, and perhaps a pink as my current selection is running ragged. I'd typically go with BB rtw, but they have a really crappy selection of rtw shirts with a Londoner collar and button cuffs right now. Plus, I'd like to give one of these MTM online experiences a shot.

BB Pros:
BB slim fit fits me quite well.
I also like the non-iron fabric (because I'm lazy with the iron).
I'm familiar with the product.

BB Cons:
Price $130/shirt.
Fewer customization options.

Modertailor pros:
Better customization.
Cheaper.


Modertailor Cons:
Unfamilar with the product sizing and fabric.

So what would you do? (half of you will probably say neither...but what the hell)

I got the email today and considered it an omen. I'm going to order one shirt for now and see how it goes. Light pink oxford cloth, 2 button cut-away with MOP buttons. All for $51 USD (including shipping).

I provided them with a Bertoni shirt measurement, the fit on that shirt is still much better than the BB slimfit.