What is the difference? Also, if anyone could explain why there is more than one language spoken between humans without references to the tower of Babel, I would appreciate it. Please think about this for a good long time before you answer.
Join Now
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
Recent Reviews
-
Initial Impressions I ordered Taylor Stitch's 10 oz indigo Cone Mills Flatout shirt (http://taylorstitch.com/products/indigo-cone-flatout). The denim shirts come in three colors: Indigo in 10...
-
Is it somebody who own this and wants to sell?
-
This was a gift from my boss. I kept it for a few months before I just sold it. It is pretty solid. Made in USA. You can't beat the quality. If I needed a sterling silver money clip I would buy a...
-
I just picked this up and I am pretty pleased. Just what I expected. I am pleased with the Bark. However, I wish it was a little darker. A great deal for $35. Comparable to other belts in the...
-
I am a thin build girl with skinny hip and bums, I normally wear a size 25 in Paige denim, and thought I give the selvedge raw a try. The 24 of New Standard is too bulky in the high waist leg,...
Styleforum Affiliate Links
- Howard Yount
- Kent Wang
- Malford of London
- Modern Tailor
- Need Supply Co.
- Neighbour
- Oak Street Bootmakers
- Portland Dry Goods
- Roden Gray
- Rick's Kansas City
- Saddleback Leather
- Self Edge
- ShopTheFinest.com
- Shrine
- Tanner Goods/Woodlands Supply
- Tate + Yoko
- Temple of jawnz
- Uncle Otis
- Virtual Clotheshorse
- Wrong Weather
- The Armoury
- A Suitable Wardrobe
- Bespoke England
- Blake
- Blue Owl
- Bodega
- Brigade
- Cedarville Store
- Context Clothing
- Crane's Country Store
- David Reeves Bespoke
- Drinkwater's Cambridge
- eHABERDASHER
- Epaulet
- Equus Leather
- A Fine Pair of Shoes
- Four Horsemen Shop
- Gordon Yao, Hong Kong
- The Hanger Project
- Henry Carter Neckwear
Dialect v. Accent
post #2 of 17
5/6/10 at 9:33pm
post #3 of 17
5/6/10 at 10:22pm
accent is simply way letters and word are pronounced. stresses may change even the sound of particular letters and letter combinations.
dialect is harder to define and the usgae depdning upn where you are. formally it would be variation derived from a mother langauge. for example pidgin englishes are dialects of various languages. in usage the defintion changes for example the the dialects of italy are nto derived form italian as it is known but most developed before italian as language existed. the same case with bayrisch it is not derivative of german but it called dialect as well.
dialect is harder to define and the usgae depdning upn where you are. formally it would be variation derived from a mother langauge. for example pidgin englishes are dialects of various languages. in usage the defintion changes for example the the dialects of italy are nto derived form italian as it is known but most developed before italian as language existed. the same case with bayrisch it is not derivative of german but it called dialect as well.
post #4 of 17
5/6/10 at 10:25pm
- hossoso
- Coward and P*ssy
-
- Posts: 7,022
- Joined: 6/2006
- Location: Seattle
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
A dialect is an actual language. An accent is usually the mispronounciation of a language. Let me explain. Haitian Creole is a language. If I, a non-creole speaker, were to attempt to speak the language and I botched the different inflections and rythms of speech, I'd have an accent.
This makes some sense but, just using America as an example, you have a difference between Boston, NY, Philadelphia, VA/NC, GA, AL, MS, Texas, Midwest & West Coast (the newscaster.) I also disagree that a dialect is an actual language. I only checked Wiki but the page claimed it to be regional differences.
post #6 of 17
5/6/10 at 11:06pm
- hossoso
- Coward and P*ssy
-
- Posts: 7,022
- Joined: 6/2006
- Location: Seattle
- Select All Posts By This User
- hossoso
- Coward and P*ssy
-
- Posts: 7,022
- Joined: 6/2006
- Location: Seattle
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Also, if anyone could explain why there is more than one language spoken between humans without references to the tower of Babel, I would appreciate it.
Don't forget about this one guys. It is way too far fetched to explain easily but I am sure someone can do it.
post #9 of 17
5/6/10 at 11:31pm
Quote:
This makes some sense but, just using America as an example, you have a difference between Boston, NY, Philadelphia, VA/NC, GA, AL, MS, Texas, Midwest & West Coast (the newscaster.) I also disagree that a dialect is an actual language. I only checked Wiki but the page claimed it to be regional differences.
I don't think Appalachian English is an accent. The Scott-Irish that went up into those mountains hundreds of years ago were isolated to the point where their language developed free of influences from anywhere else. If you were to talk to an elderly person whose language has perservered despite the influences of non-regional diction, via the proliferation of radio and TV, you'd need subtitles to understand them.
Regarding dialects I refer to Pennsylvania Dutch. This language is only alive in Amish communities within the United States. If you took a Dutch person into an Amish community they'd be able to distinguish a few words here and there but they wouldn't be able to understand it. The Amish brought the language with them and it froze in time. So although it used to be a dialect of Dutch, the fact that it only survives here makes it a language. This is why I think the line between dialect and mother tongue is dubious. It takes a bit of bigotry and nationalism to say that Haitian creole is a lingua franca and not an honest to goodness language, for example.
post #10 of 17
5/6/10 at 11:47pm
two people can speak the same dialect. They probably won't have the same accent. Also, I think of accent as someone speaking a non-native language with pronunciation from their mother tongue.
I'm no anthropology major or anything, but my best guess at this is: humans quickly learned that living in large groups was more effective for survival purposes. What started out as simple communication turned into patterns, used to convey ideas/messages. The simple fact is, the earth is a HUGE place and without any technology, even the basic wheel and the domestication of animals like horses, there might have been hundreds of years between any sets of tribes even encountering each other. So they all understand the same concepts but developed different sets of noises for what each think meant, ie a different language. Even as the populations grew and people developed the ability to survive and travel further, there were still limits because of the separation of continents.So let's say many south american languages share similar sounds, while each country still has it's own dialect or even language. They're more similar to each other as a group then they are to any language from another continent like Europe. So my explanation is mobility.
post #11 of 17
5/7/10 at 7:27am
- Posts: 13,345
- Joined: 3/2006
- Location: Here/There
- Select All Posts By This User
Historical and material considerations require adaptations/changes in the articulations and exchanges between individuals located in a place. So, people in one place will have different adaptations/needs for communication than others and, voila, different languages used to express those needs. Languages are essentially exchanges of meaning between individuals for specific purposes, related to specific settings... People living in a landlocked valley have no need for a word like "Schooner," so they won't have one until they do. Eskimos have fifteen words for snow (or whatever), but Tahitians sure don't. People say what they need to say and nothing else.
post #12 of 17
5/7/10 at 7:47am
Quote:
Historical and material considerations require adaptations/changes in the articulations and exchanges between individuals located in a place. So, people in one place will have different adaptations/needs for communication than others and, voila, different languages used to express those needs. Languages are essentially exchanges of meaning between individuals for specific purposes, related to specific settings...
People living in a landlocked valley have no need for a word like "Schooner," so they won't have one until they do. Eskimos have fifteen words for snow (or whatever), but Tahitians sure don't.
People say what they need to say and nothing else.
People living in a landlocked valley have no need for a word like "Schooner," so they won't have one until they do. Eskimos have fifteen words for snow (or whatever), but Tahitians sure don't.
People say what they need to say and nothing else.
This is crazy stuff. In my ancestral tounge we only have like 6 or 7 colors.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_colors
post #13 of 17
5/7/10 at 7:54am
- Posts: 13,345
- Joined: 3/2006
- Location: Here/There
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
This is crazy stuff. In my ancestral tounge we only have like 6 or 7 colors. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_colors
post #14 of 17
5/7/10 at 5:49pm
Quote:
I don't think Appalachian English is an accent. The Scott-Irish that went up into those mountains hundreds of years ago were isolated to the point where their language developed free of influences from anywhere else. If you were to talk to an elderly person whose language has perservered despite the influences of non-regional diction, via the proliferation of radio and TV, you'd need subtitles to understand them.
Quote:
Regarding dialects I refer to Pennsylvania Dutch. This language is only alive in Amish communities within the United States. If you took a Dutch person into an Amish community they'd be able to distinguish a few words here and there but they wouldn't be able to understand it. The Amish brought the language with them and it froze in time. So although it used to be a dialect of Dutch, the fact that it only survives here makes it a language. This is why I think the line between dialect and mother tongue is dubious. It takes a bit of bigotry and nationalism to say that Haitian creole is a lingua franca and not an honest to goodness language, for example.
post #15 of 17
5/7/10 at 6:02pm
- Posts: 14,454
- Joined: 1/2005
- Location: A bit better than yesterday, all day vomiting for the...
- Select All Posts By This User
Return Home
Back to Forum: General Chat
- Dialect v. Accent
Currently, there are 1030 Active Users
(296 Members and 734 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › Henry Carter Neckwear & Accessories: Official affiliate thread 4 minutes ago
- › things that are making you happy 5 minutes ago
- › Brooks Brothers by Alden white bucs 9D 7 minutes ago
- › ***Finally an Official Baller sneaker thread ($300 minimum)*** 9 minutes ago
- › Things that are pissing you off. 10 minutes ago
- › BNWOT Persol 2365-S 12 minutes ago
- › ***The official Alden thread *** 18 minutes ago
- › Things your dumb friends post on facebook 21 minutes ago
- › Ask a Question, Get an Answer - ask all quick questions here 22 minutes ago
- › Dieting Software 23 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Taylor Stitch Cone Mills Flatout 10 oz denim shirt by 3dials
- › Energie Bracelet by Miro Labaj
- › Brooks Brothers Sterling Silver Money Clip by deveandepot1
- › Frank and Oak Gosford Belt by deveandepot1
- › APC Petit Standard by cv123
- › The Lamb-The Lamb by j
- › Everlane Bag by deveandepot1
- › Fred Perry Vintage Twill Backpack - Navy by Mbdu Ckfu
- › Converse All Star Chuck Taylor Leather OX - Black by Mbdu Ckfu
- › Barbour International Trials Waxed Jacket - Black by Mbdu Ckfu
View: More Reviews
New Articles
- › What Tuxedo Do I Need For A Black Tie Event? by j
- › What Should I Ask My Groomsmen to Wear? by shawea
- › How Do I Look Cool? by shawea
- › What Kind of Suit Should I Buy? by shawea
- › How Should I Start My Business Wardrobe? by shawea
- › What Should I Wear To A Job Interview? by shawea
- › A Tom Ford Quantum Suiting by David Zaritsky
- › the-difference-between-fused-and-canvassed-su... by LA Guy
- › tailoring-allowances-by-jeffery-diduch-jefferyd by LA Guy
- › the-basics-of-wedding-attire by Blackhood
View: New Articles | All Articles
Home | Reviews | Forums | Articles | My Profile
About Styleforum | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 Styleforum is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map
About Styleforum | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 Styleforum is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map







My family and I, from Iowa and Minnesota, called this a commode^
My first cousin, who grew up in North Carolina, called this a commode^