Quote:
Originally Posted by
HORNS 
Would you guys find it a sign of professional ignorance if they asked you if you wanted the martini made with gin or vodka?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Piobaire 
Maybe not ignorance on the bartender's part, I mean he at least realized martini =! automatically mean vodka, but it would certainly tell me much about the crowd that usually goes there.
Now, what would impress me would be if the bartender stirred the martinin or even, heaven forbid, cracked some ice too.
This.
I'm actually less concerned with what he says than if he leaves me with the impression that he doesn't even realize that a martini is made with gin. I understand the world we live in and that most people don't know that today...but he's a bartender, he should know better. As long as he knows better, that's fine.
If you came to my town I could take you to one spot and show you the difference better than I could explain it. I can walk into a particular bar I know that is competently staffed. The bartenders are grownups who take their job seriously. They
do actually stir their martinis with cracked ice. They know that a proper Manhattan is served with a dash of bitters. They remember your name and what you like to drink even if you've only been in a few times.
I can then take you right across the street where the (extremely popular) watering hole bar is staffed with a bunch of untrained 20-somethings designed only to look pretty and bring in the female customers. If I got behind the bar and mixed my drink myself they'd still find a way to screw it up for me. Sadly I still go there quite frequently because its a sushi place that serves very good sushi...the bar staff is just very incompentent.
It's really not that hard, it just takes attention to detail.