Originally Posted by NorCal
But truth be told I really know shit about these guys. If JH and Co. think he's the man I guess that's good enough for me.
I think I'd agree with that, I don't hate Carpenter, I just hate the strategy (or lack thereof) with which we aquired him. James Carpenter might turn out to be a stud at RT for all I know (would be REALLY NICE), but it seemed like a reactionary pick after Cameron Jordan went off the board. I think that's who the 'Hawks had (pre)decided on taking. Would have been quite a coup if they'd have been able to pull that off.
I'm a big proponent of taking the BPA, and somehow I doubt he was in fact, the highest rated player on the Seahawks board. I guess I'll never know.
I live about 2700 feet away from the Seahawks war-room, maybe I should write BPA on a sign and walk down there to picket.
Lets just hope they can pick up a QB somewhere, another season of AS scares me.
Well just look at it this way, you can have one more year of Smith, then draft Luck high next year, or you can have Donovan McNabb for two or three years, and then be in the same situation you are in right now.