fwiw i'm a peasant and i enjoyed the movie quite a bit. i didn't like the knave (or the queen's lover or whatever), i thought the plot about the one champion thingy was kinda cheesy, as was the final battle scene and the old feminist rising up against the tide of oppressive bourgeoisie, but i really really liked the colorful landscape, johnny depp's dancing at the end (i yelled out david elsewhere in the middle of it -_-;; and apparently that was him. he's credited somewhere), i liked his twist on things like the reason why it's an older alice, i liked mia wkaisoiajefzek something and the red queen. johnny depp reminded me a lot of his character on charlie and the chocolate factory. i didn't like the make up on anne hathaway (yeah. dumb, i know) and that stupid "i vowed never to harm a living creature line" (again i thought the champion thingy was really cheesy).
the plot devices was kinda cheesy (i feel could have been more well thought out), but the visual imagery was fun too watch. the movie in general was just fun to watch.
i'd watch it again with younger nephews on DVD.