Bodileys' customer service is, in my experience, nothing short of amazing. When you have a problem with an order, most companies seem to view it as an annoyance that should be dealt with using as little effort as possible. Sarah, who seems to handle most Bodileys' customer service, views a problem with an order as an opportunity to make Bodileys a better company. Here is an experience that I had with them.
I cannot recommend Bodileys and Sarah highly enough. This is kind of heresy on SF but even if Pediwear is slightly cheaper, it is well-worth dealing with Bodileys just for their service and helpful attitude.
I definitely second this. Sarah has been extremely pleasant to deal with and very helpful: great attitude, extremely attentive to emails, frequent order updates, etc. FYI she has informed me that they will soon start offering Alfred Sarget shoes once they get their website updated.