Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
And if you seriously cannot find women without makeup that's pretty sad because pssst here's a secret: your mother your potential mates, sisters, daughters, they aren't born with makeup, and one day if you're not careful you might have to see them without it.
Women get raped all the time by straight men, but nobody would consider an average straight man creepy, but when there are gay fetishists that MIGHT target you are they considered creepy. Think for a second how that reflects on your characters.
Feel free to look up stats of rapists by sexual orientation assuming you don't pull up a Westboro citation.
I generally don't disagree with what you're saying.
Dirty sock fetish is pretty creepy by most standards, whether it's straight or gay. It's unsanitary and, imho, sartorially off-putting.
A man with a stocking over his head sitting on a bed in that manner looks pretty menacing by any standards. If you add the story about one of the posters here getting harassed and stalked by a couple of guys, in this particular fetish community, who fantasises about raping suited men - it's pretty creepy (rape culture is creepy on all sides of the fence).