Both pairs came in the mail today. Some quick thoughts:
Andy boots: These run about a size large, and I ordered a size down, so that's good. For whatever reason, I'm not all that impressed with the leather. They look like they could be styled well - the opening of the shaft is extra-wide, so they're pretty much meant for tucking - but probably not the kind of thing I'd wear all that often. Also, they're really awkward to get on, probably exacerbated by my large feet and high instep.
Dick boots: The leather's tough and distressed, not anything mind blowing but definitely interesting. They're a little wacky without necessarily coming across as golf-ninja specifically. They have a chunky sole and somewhat bulbous toe, and they might go pretty well with the LVCs I just picked up. Unfortunately, these definitely run TTS. I ordered a 44, and there's no way I could wear them.