I have basically two brown dress shoes and two black. Just discovered today that the "beater" pair of black shoes - some not-great square-toed rockports - had almost completely separated from the sole in the heel. Obviously, these need replacing.
Other black pair is a brand-new (this past Christmas) cap-toed Oxford by Johnston & Murphy. Yeah, sorry.
I'm on a budget so I'd like to keep this second pair right around $100. If it exonerates previous choices, my issue is that I have big feet, and take generally a 15W or 16D (sometimes 16W too; depends on the maker). I'd also like something that it's possible to walk around in a lot without falling apart (I'm in a city, have no car, walk to train to work, etc. etc.).
Any tips? Thanks!