Because people have been posting different reviews here, in random fashion thoughts ( I think) and in the HMxMMM thread.
Since you got no real answer:
It's nice, atleast the stuff I tried on
The boots are the best I've seen for 300 (shape is awesome and leather is rather nice)
The camel overcoat is cool, fit is good
The painted jeans feel sturdy and fall awesome
On sale, as you asked in some other thread, I definitely think the stuff is good value (not comparing to buying from B&S or sufu)