Really like that first shot. In the last shot, I know it's cold outside, but I feel like your accessories are pulling you in too many different directions.
Originally Posted by slstr
The first picture looks awesome though, and then it just gets worse
Edit: just to expand on my point and not aimlessly bash you, in the untucked version there is this smooth, unbroken line from the tapered, slim jeans down to the toe of the sleek sidezips, which IMO is the appeal of that type of boot. When you roll/tuck it looks a lot sloppier and 'chunkier', for want of a better word, and it breaks the line. It works with less elegant boots, but with sidezips it just doesn't look great, in my opinion.
Originally Posted by brad-t
your perception is warped. untucked and unrolled looks best
This I guess looks alright if it pleases you but I still think it looks too mundane to wear with a red zipper trench
I'm okay with this too but you'd probably feel the same as you do about the tuck
Also, hereby nominate fireflygrave for best "new" poster.
...And NewYorkRanger for most stylish grandma.
I agree with what everyone else is saying, it looks way better without the tuck. Jeans aren't good for tucking in general, and neither are the vast majority of side/back-zips. Even in those runway pics it doesn't look good. It kind of reminds me of those girls on campus that tuck their juicy sweatpants into uggs.