But once again you ignore the factor of fatigue. Once a trend reaches a saturation point as Unc argues, the feeling of fatigue over that trend outweighs any classic aesthetic value that trend has. "Played out" isn't a judgment of absolute aesthetic value, it's as I said before an expression of fatigue.
No, I get it. We all get tired of things in our closet at some point. I still don't like that critique - it irks me As you've probably noticed, I'm more interested in things that look good and boring, than things that look innovative and edgy without looking that great. I do appreciate that people get bored with the former and like to see edgy outfits in the thread. It's natural.