Sweater is SNS Herning Amalgam cardigan (there's a pullover version of the Amalgam as well). Shirt is Modern Tailor. MTM and box fresh with no additional alterations. I think I've just about nailed down the fit I want, although I may make a couple more tweaks to the measurements next time I order from them.
(Added details to the original post.)
Hows the material of the modern tailor shirt? was it a cotton ploy blend or cotton 2 ply? I would say you pretty much nail the fit for the shirt, nice fit