Yeah this doesn't look right. I think it's as much the weird cotton henley placket on your midlayer than the collar. If you want to look "neat," your collar points should sit inside your sweater, which is possible on non-buttondown-collar shirts. Some collars and sweaters just weren't meant to fit together.
If you're wearing an overshirt or something (so, two collars) the collars should still sit quietly and not get all rowdy like that.
Okay, so it's not just a me thing. Thank you. I see some SFers pull off similar looks, but I feel like an asshole wearing a collared shirt under a sweater (the types I most frequently wear). Need to figure this out better, then.
Edited by Liam O - 10/21/13 at 10:20am