SVB, I normally really like your fits. The past few you've posted have been very good. This latest one, however, it seems to me like the patterns clash a little bit. I don't really agree with Teger about the shape of the jacket on you, but I would agree with SB regarding the hem length.
All of Stanley's jackets look fine and the criticisms are kind of bizarre. There is room to quibble about length or even waist suppression, but don't pretend that's anything more than personal preference -- folks in CM would probably say the jackets are on the short side if anything, in context.
I do agree with BiggSkip about the patterns in the last one, though. The shirt and jacket don't look right together IMO.