To be clear, you do NOT want to put cream-style polish on shell cordovan shoes. Only use wax-based polish (which is what the Alden product is).
I hope this does not get too off-topic but I just purchased my first pair of shell cordovan shoes (AE MacNeil) and went to AE's website and watched their video on caring for shell cordovan shoes and purchased their cordovan cream. Are you saying this is actually not good to use on the shoes? I would appreciate some more insight into this. Thank you.
I hope this does not get too off-topic but I just purchased my first pair of shell cordovan shoes (AE MacNeil) and went to AE's website and watched their video on caring for shell cordovan shoes and purchased their cordovan cream.
Are you saying this is actually not good to use on the shoes? I would appreciate some more insight into this. Thank you.
I've used AE's cordovan cream for years, and it works very well. I'm also a fan of paste, but I use AE cordo cream for my #8 and other burgundy shells.
I have had mixed results. For the most part they are just fine. Very recently, during a light rain my new unpolished pair of black AE Leeds got slightly wet. The shell reacted so poorly that I consider them toi be pretty much ruined. They literally developed an odd rough surface and small cracking, whereas they had previously been smooth as silk. I partially blame myself as I suspect some wax polish would have gone a long way in protecting them. I also suspect that perhaps the shells were not from Horween, or somehow defective.
Since making this thread, my shells have seen a good bit of rain. Maybe 5-7 rainy outings. Here is what they look like without ever using cream, paste, wax, or polish. I simply brushed them and buffed with a cotton cloth.
Made the mistake of wearing my vintage black shell cordovan Bostonian Tassel loafers in a driving rain storm to attend a retirement party. I could have worn my waterproof cole haans or even put on overshoes which I keep in my office but i figured the shell would be fine. My feet stayed warm and dry within the shoes and i noticed nothing amiss. The next day i looked at the loafers and saw cracking in the fold wear a little excess polish was and also micro-cracks across the stitching. My thinking is that the shell was affected by the direct exposure to the car's heater on the two hour drive home. The shell dried by artificial means. I have metal tins of Venetian and should have taken the shoes off prior to driving home and then as soon as I got home i should have Venetianed the sh## out of them. Learned a lesson, I have been creaming the other shell i own repeatedly and brushing.
I'm glad there is one less pair of tassel loafers in the world but I'm sorry for you loss, if it is indeed a loss.
Is it just the polish that's cracking? Even with artifical drying, unless the heater was super hot, shouldn't crack them. Try cleaning them off and using a little conditioner.