or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Who has love for black suits?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Who has love for black suits? - Page 4

post #46 of 70
Was it discussed why black suits are considered normative in in Asian countries? I always found it somewhat dreary and more because it's an easy choice than for any culturally-ingrained reasons. Interestingly, in Japan black suits are quite standard and expected for funerals, yet people who look like they don't give a darn can always be seen shuffling around in baggy black suits to work every day, too (most people). As to black trousers, I was having the same discussion with someone recently: I think it's just too funerary (and bland) looking for everyday wear, but he was telling me that black trousers with white shirt is the height of simplistic minimalism. I think it's a bit brutal myself.
post #47 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by lasbar View Post
I was wearing one recently to a party I went to and I received some many compliments that I was internally having a fit of laughter thinking of all the SF anti-black suits brigade.

To be fair , I was only wearing that suit because I didn't want to go there with a bespoke suit and getting some cigarette burns on it while dancing away.

I have the right high contrast complexion but it is still amazing that I receive more compliments wearing a cheap black Canali suit than a great bespoke flannel one.

Is it not just ironic?

After posting on this thread a few days ago, I dug out my old black corduroy suit from APC (bought around 2000-2001). I was delighted that it still fit me - my wife and sister-in-law both said it looked great. I wore it to a local bar and some friends complimented me on my look...
post #48 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by softy View Post
As to black trousers, I was having the same discussion with someone recently: I think it's just too funerary (and bland) looking for everyday wear, but he was telling me that black trousers with white shirt is the height of simplistic minimalism. I think it's a bit brutal myself.

Outside of formal events and fancy evenings, plain black suit/trousers and white shirt is not a good look - this is probably one of the core reasons why some people do not like black suits.

With a plain black suit/trousers: Go for a light coloured or some form of stripe shirt, if required a tie, polished black shoes and possibly add a pocket square - a much better use of black and does not look bland.
post #49 of 70
I bought my only black suit in college (Joseph Abboud). They seemed to be in fashion, since I saw so many people wearing them to and from interviews on campus, so I thought I should get one too. I already had a nice navy suit.

Upon reflection, a large portion of the people I saw wearing them were asian, so that may have had something to do with their popularity.

I still wear the black suit to work about once every one or two weeks. With a white shirt and a bright tie, it looks great. Fit is much more important than color. Unless its green or brown - yuck.
post #50 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by HHD View Post
After posting on this thread a few days ago, I dug out my old black corduroy suit from APC (bought around 2000-2001). I was delighted that it still fit me - my wife and sister-in-law both said it looked great. I wore it to a local bar and some friends complimented me on my look...

Just to remember that Sf is a sartorial heaven reserved for the happy few.

We're cut from the real sartorial and fashion world and it is funny to see how relevant or irrelevant are our certitudes...
post #51 of 70
It is okay but I find it very common. Everyone feel affection for black color.
post #52 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by lasbar View Post
I was wearing one recently to a party I went to and I received some many compliments that I was internally having a fit of laughter thinking of all the SF anti-black suits brigade.

To be fair , I was only wearing that suit because I didn't want to go there with a bespoke suit and getting some cigarette burns on it while dancing away.

I have the right high contrast complexion but it is still amazing that I receive more compliments wearing a cheap black Canali suit than a great bespoke flannel one.

Is it not just ironic?
Frankly, compliments are little indication of either the appropriateness or attractiveness of a particular garment. People in general and women in particular have a tendency to notice and comment on the unusual or notable. When they are neutrally or favorably disposed towards you, these comments usually take the form of a compliment. It means only that they noticed that particular garment. When I receive such compliments, I generally take them to mean I did not incorporate the complimented item into what I was wearing in such a way that it formed a coherent whole. The best compliments are those that don't mention a particular item.
post #53 of 70
While I am no longer as much of a fan as the black suit as I was back in school, it can still look good if worn slim. That said, I'm not a fan of plain black suits at daytime, unless you're in really good shape, in which case you're excused. Black suits/blazers/sports jackets with some texture on the other hand, can be a thing of immense beauty, as if it had depths that your eyes cannot help but be drawn into.
post #54 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by dah328 View Post
Frankly, compliments are little indication of either the appropriateness or attractiveness of a particular garment. People in general and women in particular have a tendency to notice and comment on the unusual or notable. When they are neutrally or favorably disposed towards you, these comments usually take the form of a compliment. It means only that they noticed that particular garment. When I receive such compliments, I generally take them to mean I did not incorporate the complimented item into what I was wearing in such a way that it formed a coherent whole. The best compliments are those that don't mention a particular item.

I don't mean to be rude, but frankly I would rather have compliments from hot women than the approval of my learned peers on this website. (And a black corduroy suit is perfectly appropriate for a bar in the bobo third arrondisement.)
post #55 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by dah328 View Post
Frankly, compliments are little indication of either the appropriateness or attractiveness of a particular garment. People in general and women in particular have a tendency to notice and comment on the unusual or notable. When they are neutrally or favorably disposed towards you, these comments usually take the form of a compliment. It means only that they noticed that particular garment. When I receive such compliments, I generally take them to mean I did not incorporate the complimented item into what I was wearing in such a way that it formed a coherent whole. The best compliments are those that don't mention a particular item.

I prefer women find me attractive than the garment I have chosen to wear that night.

We could also talk ad vitam aeternam about the stimuli behind our sartorial choices and the relationship between our sartorial aura/persona and the rest of the world.

I personally love looking relevant to the situation i'm evolving in and in a trendy nightclub ,a black suit is more relevant than a flannel one .

With sartorially advanced people , it is also true that the best compliments are the silent ones but they're not the norm.

In every social or networking environment, looking good is sometimes more important than looking right, even if the shallowness of this argument is evident.

The pleasure of looking good prevails sometimes over the pleasure of the cloth.

I'm vain and that is my downfall.
post #56 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by HHD View Post
I don't mean to be rude, but frankly I would rather have compliments from hot women than the approval of my learned peers on this website.
post #57 of 70
I too own a black suit that I wear to work semi-often. The rest of my work rotation is either gray, blue, or chocolate. I've never seen the black suit as a major faux pas. I don't really see the big deal, honestly.
post #58 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by rgoldstein View Post
I too own a black suit that I wear to work semi-often. The rest of my work rotation is either gray, blue, or chocolate. I've never seen the black suit as a major faux pas. I don't really see the big deal, honestly.

Shouldn't be wearing brown to work either :P
post #59 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by ferguscan View Post
Shouldn't be wearing brown to work either :P

Brown is not a work colour if I may use that terminology.

In most profession ,wearing a dark brown/chocolate suit will be seen as a fashion faux-pas.

I t can look fantastic if you have the right high contrast complexion but it is more casual colour to wear outside work.
post #60 of 70
Quote:
Originally Posted by ferguscan View Post
Shouldn't be wearing brown to work either :P

I refuse to wear only blue and grey to work everyday. Thats ridiculously boring no matter who you are or how beautiful the suit in question is.

Besides, it isn't ESPN talking head shiny chocolate brown, and I don't wear loud ties or pocket squares with it. Its wool and its rather subdued, yet still different enough. Resembles this:



I've received some serious compliments from both male and female clients as well as my co-workers.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Who has love for black suits?