no, mine were an inch longer than they should have been, in my mind. From the tip of the boot (not the soul, but where the leather upper ended) to the tip of my big toe, was over 2 inches. So in my mind, that's about an inch long, especially considering this is not a sharp, pointy toe box, but rather a rounded one. sorry to beat a dead horse here with the sizing. 'don't mean to bogaard the thread. They're awesome boots.