What's the appeal of the wings/horns x dayton service boots - Page 3

lol. itt. people learn that details do matter and it's not as easy finding cheap replicas as they think. Also, oxnard makes me miss the days of the US$ killing the CAD

So is there anybody out there that got a pair from Dayton?! How was the process cause they aren't on their website.

Those days seem like they never happened now.

Cansty, I know this too. What's with people speaking as if their only encounter with a brand or interaction is the one and only fact? They were going for $239, same boot as the W+H just not distressed. And who says they want a cheap replica? I just don't want to buy a boot where two companies are trying to take a dip out of a well that I dug in effect doubling the price. '

If you want some really funny evidence of the Wings+Horns boot hype/circle-jerk go here: http://www.styleforum.net/showthread...54#post2753254 to see these boots called 'REALLY ugly' amongst other things. Fucking gold.

Whatever, only each person can decide if a product is "worth" the money. What does that even mean? Some people will pay $4000.00 for a Kiton or Brioni suit. Is it worth the price? Sure, if you'll wear it and enjoy it. But all the hand work that goes in to those suits means nothing if you don't feel good in it. Is Dior worth the price? It's a $1700.00 suit. That's a lot for many people. But still they'll pay for it because to them it's worth it whether there's any hand work in it or not. So, buy what you like. Getting bogged down with technical details makes no sense sometimes, because really determining if a product is worth the price is a tricky business. And in the end, it's all about if you are happy with what you got. At least that's my opinion.

^ So true.... Brinbro, just stating my personal exp, maybe you got a different quote, thats cool, not saying you lying or anything, just saying I didnt see that value in saving 2 bills for something that wasnt going to be the same as I really wanted, and after dayton sent me pics of them I realized they also didnt look nearly as nice as the legit collab ones. Believe me man, Im a no-bs kind of guy and even though I really dont have a spending limit, I pride myself in always getting the best deal I can for what I want, and I was really into getting these cheaper but again to me there was no alternative that really matched or top them imo, thats not to say they're not overpriced @retail, but everyone has their own price/quality point in mind.

I feel like I will be telling my grand kids about the crazy days of SNES and the USD being worth two CADs, those days are long gone now.
Brinbro I realize what your getting at with the picture of the regular Dayton boots but that really just supports the fact that they are made of completely different materials. I think there are enough differences to warrant an exclusion of comparisons here, it is two completely different products. Also Dayton boots have goodyear welts which Fiorentini + Baker boots do not, which is a small detail yes but it can have a great impact on the long-term durability of the shoe. Don't get me wrong F+B makes wonderful footwear too but there are more than enough small details and differences between the two brands (and any other brand mentioned here).
When you have such greatly varied and different products it really doesn't make sense to try and make such disparaging comparisons of value and worth.

Have definitely noticed lately people talking as if something somewhat similar is "pretty much the same" and thus can be readily substituted for what happens to be a more expensive version of said item.

Seems like you're the only one in this thread who needs to "relax". What's with the attitude?

Actually, I ordered the 745 from gimmeshoes and back it went. Cool enough looking boot, but the leather was paper thin and the welting left much to be desired. Overall, the boot just didn't feel all that substantial. They reminded me of the "Made in Mexico" Fryes. I showed them to my cobbler and he wasn't impressed. Nice for walking around town, but I would not put the same faith in them that I have in Frye USA, Buttero, NDC, Red Wing etc. to ride my motorcycle and just plain beat the hell out of.

Face it, most boots are overpriced, but go ahead and actually handle both the 745 and the W+H. Formulate your own opinion. I have, and I think the W+H, at $720 is a better value than the F&B at $420.

So two people criticize a hideous boot similar to the W+H service boot, and that confirms the hype/circle-jerk for the W+H boot is bullshit? I don't buy it.

I do think it is strange that so many people on here sell them at well below retail. Is it a matter of people using a product that holds it's value fairly well for quick, substantial cash, or is there another reason?

It's so hard to find a good pair of boots. It's all in the details. Apparently only Dayton and Wings+Horns can figure it out. Hope I can one day afford them. I want some BAD!

I have seen the W+H boots many times, only tried them on for a few minutes... they seem well made to me but not somehow superior to a lot of other boots. My NiCos definitely feel more solid. Talked to an outdoor enthusiast? guy at the last sample sale who sold his W+HxDayton after 6 months or so's wear, on grounds that he felt when wearing them that he was wearing a fashion boot, not a boot boot, and didn't have confidence that they could stand up to weather / salt etc. he was putting them through in the long run. Which surprised me, because they certainly seem like they should be able to last for quite a while despite punishment.

This whole argument is so tired. Whether or not something is overpriced is so subjective it's rarely worth discussing. Implying that someone along the chain is unfairly marking these boots up is simply wrong though. Dayton makes the boots, then marks them up, W+H buys the boots, distresses them and then marks them up, retailers then purchase the boots, and obviously mark them up too. No one in this process is stepping outside of what is considered a standard retail mark up. This is simply the way a collaboration of this nature works. The product may pass through an extra set of hands, but it's the only way this specific product can reach the consumer. The comparison of the non-distressed version of the boot does not hold much weight as it is simply a different product. Washed KMW jeans cost more than the raw version of the same cut. If you don't like the treatment then don't buy the product, but the fact remains that every additional process will add to the final cost.

I think the boots are great and i have yet to find another pair that nails the aesthetic, while preserving the level of craftsmanship. That being said, they are definitely more of a 'fashion' boot to me. The leather sole makes for a great profile, but isn't really the best option for rainy North West weather.

I also think footwear is probably the only area where the SF emphasis on quality is completely justified. A poorly made pair of shoes will literally fall apart earlier than a higher quality pair. Cost-per-wear is a legitimate consideration when buying a pair of boots, and a welted sole is a critical and often decisive feature.

Fire!

Yea, i mean i think it might've started initially with AA hoodies being the same as W&H and then a bunch of people end up unhappy with their aa hoodies. Then the next big thing was Jcrew shirts (tailored or not) being the same as BoO but i think people saw there was an obvious difference despite both being oxford cloth shirts. F&B boots are cool and all. I definitely think they're quite different though so i don't understand the "just buy F&B boots instead" kinda stuff. I've handled them at barneys plenty of times, they're pretty solid. Not sure they're not also "overpriced" whatever that means. Don't think they're the same but they're attractive boots as well.

Boots are hard to find because while "black leather boot" is pretty easy, finding all the small little details of type of leather, finishing, sole, toe shape, last, height, silhouette, distressing, and other details. People want different things a lot of times but there is a lot of crap to think about if you're being picky

I should have those boots in by today or Monday latest. Those pictures were taken by the sales rep. For those curious about ordering from Dayton, you need to call them and inquire about the Wings+Horns model. I believe they have a 5.5 with a leather sole remaining and a few sparse sizes. I lucked out and grabbed the last 8 size but it's with an oil resistant sole as opposed to a leather sole. Was it worth it? Yes, partly because I got a W+H "substitute" at half the price and also the Dayton guarantee of excellent craftsmanship. W+H didn't just choose any random boot maker to do a collab with, Dayton has been around and is tried and true. The construction is impeccable according to many people and I'm just stoked to have a Dayton boot now.