C&J Savile or Weymouth?

Weymouth.

Savile. I think whole cuts are overhyped around here. But the Weymouths are more versatile, if you can live with the styling.

+1 or just get both.

Not when it comes to shoes.

Depends on your shoe situation. Do you already have a wholecut? A monk strap? When I was considering which to get (my choice was the same as yours), I chose the Savile based on the fact that I already had the Loake Norwich in my collection, and it's pretty similar to the Weymouth.

When you've spent a little while longer here, you'll understand.

Both, then buy Selbourne and Millbank for good measure. That would make a good start, methinks!

No. Same last.

Weymouth.

EDIT: Buckles are not sleek.

Disclosure: I own the Savile but not the Weymouth.

Weymouth-I have it in two colors and they constantly get complimented. They shine up beautifully.

not a big fan of the plain-vamped, large, single-buckle monk straps. they remind me too much of the footwear worn on the Mayflower and pilgrims. i suppose.

get the weymouth.

It really does depend on your needs. I own both, but I've worn the Weymouth (and not gotten around to wearing the Saville yet - don't ask) and I REALLY enjoy wearing them. They are very comfortable and I've always been a fan of wholecuts.

But the Saville is a nice shoe also.

Decisions, decisions.

Clint