Quote:
Originally Posted by
mrchariybrown 
Because most of the big boards live by bro-science. And people are afraid to put on a couple pounds and invest time into this type of diet before seeing the returns.
While it may not be the best approach for fatties, I feel it can work wonders for most.
This doesn't exactly sound right to me.
Firstly, a huge amount of the material out there is about gaining weight, ignoring fat, so I don't find it plausible that the mega cheat diet fails to gain traction because of a fear of food. These concepts are very prevalent, even among routines and plans which are not strictly diet related (see SS discussion 20 posts ago).
Secondly, I'm not sure what to read into your first sentence. Bro-science has variable meanings and "big boards" tend to run in cycles discussing every lunatic trend every so few weeks, so the mega cheats would inevitably get some play on them.
Lastly, if we're dismissing diets as bro-science, what category would you place your mega cheats in today? There seems to be an issue with the diet if I follow you correctly as you have been suggesting a failure to gain weight for several months now. Would that not require that you inevitably call the diet a failure and bro-science?