I have both, and I prefer the one on the left. The check is more 'interesting' and I like the dash of colour. Interestingly I always assumed I would prefer the second - but after a few months I have worn the first much more.
Also have a couple of their cashmere scarves, including a black-and-white glencheck with a purple overcheck that I recently got at Tie Your Tie in Florence - lovely
I love Drakes stuff. I have the white-dark blue small check tie, the brown-white repp tie, a couple of paisley print ties, and one of their paisley silk scarves. I just ordered from Will the red dot silk scarf he wrote about a few weeks ago. I'll try to post pics later.