The Overdye oxfords are freaking fantastic. If you go TTS, they're closer to a cropped silhouette - on the shorter side, but still tuckable as long as your pants aren't extremely low-rise. I've taken to sizing up one in the BD fit for a bit more in the shoulders while maintaining the trim body and the fit is amazing - very tuck-appropriate.
I think you'll be happy either way.
And yes, shared, Mauro. Good luck
EDIT; whoops, should really go to the next page to see something's been answered first.
haha I'll second the overdyes. I have a kickass blue and slate and they are great. i live in them. tucking isn't a problem at all. they are really hearty shirts.
just got a salt n pepper hoodie and buffalo plaid shirt in the mail. both are awesome but i was a little surprised how thin the buffalo plaid is. definitely more of a warm weather shirt but its great regardless. thanks WvG!