I've got the same shoes and a black grenadine on the way too...CAN'T WAIT
Edit: Just picked them up from the post office. They are indeed amazing shoes--almost perfect. I feel a bit churlish pointing this out, but i notice the "toe cap-line" (not sure what it's really called) on the left shoe is slightly uneven. It's probably not something anyone else would notice but it kind of bothers me...would I be justified in returning these or is this fairly common? I looked at my AE PAs and the lines were uniformly straight. Am I being too picky?
If you're not 100% happy, send them back. I see what you're talking about and it is picky, but you have every right to be picky.