CD nailed the fit he was going for. I also think his button stance is perfect for his build. I suspect your hesitation has to deal with personal preferences, such as the fact CD likes his jackets on the shorter side and I'm personally not a fan of how slim the shoulders are on his jacket. I think he could stand to extend his shoulders a little bit, but that is personal preference.
Shoulders were my fav part. I love the way my shoulders fit and I love the way his fit.
I believe he is also a 38L.
Us 38Ls must just have great shoulders. Hm.