I ordered a polo in every color offered so far. They came in yesterday and fit perfectly. The sleeves don't grab and bunch up but they aren't loose either, the length is ideal and the body is snug without being tight (the collar is nice too, but that's been discussed already).
Just keep pumping out more colors of these and I'll keep picking them up.
This is first time I heard of polo shirts being too prep and hard to pull off. Dress up in jacket and trousers, dress down in shorts and thongs (the footwear) to go to the beach - they're as easy as they come. They're just t-shirts with a collar. Toddlers all the way to seniors wear them and can be worn without appearing out of place among peers.