Difficult to tell exactly from the pictures, especially Laymanx's photo, but I would say both of them are decent fits.
Laymanx, please let us know your chest size, the stated chest size of the coat, and the exact p2p of your coat. That will add to the body of knowledge of the fit of these coats.
Picked my peacoat up from the tailors. Wearing my thickest flannel underneath and it's still a bit roomy.