I bought the Elgin in a 10D, compared to my other 5-last shoes in 10.5D, and it fits me equally. The saleswoman at the Shoe Bank told me that the "rough collection" run a half-size big because the leather upper has to stretch over a bigger area due to the shoe construction. I'm sure somebody who understands what's going on could give a better explanation than me.
Post pics! I love the Rough Collection and love seeing pics.