I wear the same size in Leeds as I do in Alden Barrie.
Call or email your order. 2 for $200 is long over, and they only seem to have those every 6 months. Seconds are hit or miss, there are a lot of reasons they decide they can't sell a shoe retail. You can get anything from a first quality shoe that was a store return to something horribly disfigured, though most often they seem to have only slight imperfections.
You can buy seconds online. You just email them your credit card information. I know from personal experience.
firstname.lastname@example.org, make sure that you state your shoe size and width.