I would probably order a 9E or 9EEE. I would suggest going to an AE store and trying them out first. I see you are in NYC. There are multiple AE stores in Manhattan.
Thanks... 9.5E/EEE or 9E/EEE?
I currently don't have time to go to the AE stores in Manhattan, due to work. So, I'll take advantage of Amazon's good return policy for now.