I was excited to get my shell Macneil seconds today, but unfortunately they will be going back. Left shoe looked great, but the medallion of the right is cracked. They also looked like they had been sitting on the shelf for a LONG time (dry, dusty, etc), though that could have been remedied with some TLC.
I'm 1 for 3 on seconds now. Beginning to think it's not worth the time, though the discounts that can be had are really deep.