Just received my black McTavish pre-loved from eBay. Overall I'm happy with the condition of the shoes, especially for the $100 I paid. Few questions though for those that own Mctavish:
As you might see in the pics I feel like the back of the shoe doesn't hug my heel. When I walk my heel does not pop out at all but the side and back areas of my ankle doesn't feel like the leather is hugging it, if I'm making sense. Could this be because they were worn by someone else and in time the leather will form to my foot shape? Maybe I should try on a 9.5 or instead of 10D get a little narrower shoe or maybe it's just the way they fit. Please advise
You have no gap in your lacing and a visible gap around your heel. I would try 1/2 size down.